!"#$%&'()$"'*+,-$&-(%./+(0-+12345+6-7$"'"8-/+'"9+
:'%;3<%)=-+<."'&)87+:)(0$>(+?@$()8+A'((-%
!"#$%&'(&)*"+,-.**&/&0"1&)."2%3*.4&&
56673899:2+$%(:2;9<<<=><<<?>@AAB>=??C&
https://orcid.org/0009-0009-4672-4876 &
D&E<EF&!"#$%&'(&)*"+,-.**&G&H**&2$;563&2.3.2#.%(&
&I$+.13.%&J1%.2&65.&01K:2L"6$:1>)JMM*.&N."+.KJ*>O3.&I$+.13.&P0)NOI>Q(?R(
H72$*&E<EF
BC7(%'8(
S.&72.3.16& " &J1$T$.%&K2"L.-:2,&+:LM$1$1;&)."2%3*.4U3&$1#"2$"16>M"3.%&-"27>%2$#.&2.3:1"1+.&-$65&
)*"+,-.**U3&V!0W>O&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&L.62$+(&)."2%3*.4U3&6.L7:2"*&$1#"2$"16&X
<
&Y&?&3&"1%&K:2+.&+:136"16&
!
"
& Y& #9+X
<
E
& 6:;.65.2& $L7*4& "& 1"6J2"*&"1;J*"2&K2.ZJ.1+4& [
<
& Y& E\9X
<
& Y& E\& ]^(& S.& 35:-& 65"6& 65$3&
2.3:1"1+.& "2$3.3& "3& "& +J2#"6J2.& .$;.1L:%.& :K& "1& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& L.62$+& +:1362J+6.%& -$65$1& 65.&
V!0W>O& K2"L.-:2,(& _5.& 2"%$J3& T$.*%& $
%
`& :2$;$1"**4& $162:%J+.%& "3& "& ;.:L.62$+& -"27>MJMM*.&
%.3+2$76:2`& $3& 72:L:6.%& 6:& "1& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& +::2%$1"6.& &
$
(& aL"**& :3+$**"6$:13& $1& 65$3& +::2%$1"6.&
3"6$3K4& '
E
Pb&
$
R9'X
E
& c& [
<
E
& b&
$
& Y& <`& 72:#$%$1;& "& 7J2.*4& ;.:L.62$+& %.2$#"6$:1& :K& 65.& -"27>%2$#.&
2.3:1"1+.&-$65:J6&.d:6$+&L"66.2(&S.&.d6.1%&65.&+:1362J+6$:1&6:&65.&35$K6&#.+6:2&(
)
&:K&"&-"27&L.62$+&
"1%&%.L:1362"6.&65"6&MJMM*.&%41"L$+3&K:**:-&;.:%.3$+3&$1&"1&.d6.1%.%&+:1T$;J2"6$:1&37 "+.&P*
%
`&&
+
R(&
_5$3& 72:%J+.3& "77"2.16& 3J7.2>.KT$+$.1+4& -5$*.& 72.3.2#$1;& *:+"*& +"J3"*$64(& H& +:L7*.6.& #"2$"6$:1"*&
K:2LJ*"6$:1& $3& 72.3.16.%`& "1%& 65.& J1$T$.%& 65.:24& 3J;;.363& "& +:1+2.6.& 3$LJ*"6$:1& "2+5$6.+6J2.& K:2&
1JL.2$+"*&.d7*:2"6$:1&:K&-"27>MJMM*.&%41"L$+3(
NHea8&<A(E<(e#`&<A(E<(fM`&@=(B<(eK&&g&&h.4-:2%38&-"27&%2$#.`&$1K:2L"6$:1&;.:L.624`&.d:6$+&L"66.2`&H*+JM$.22.&
L.62$+`&2.3:1"1+.
Dedication. This work is dedicated to my wife, Ashley
Dawn, and to our kids — Jesse, Ayden, and Kylee —
who keep my world anchored while I go chasing
strange geometries at the edge of what we can
currently prove. Whatever shape these informational
bubbles finally take, the point of all of it is simple: to
leave you a universe that is a little more
understandable, a little more peaceful, and a little
more honest than the one I started in.
DE+!"(%$9>8()$"
_5.& 1:6$:1& 65"6& ;.1.2"*& 2.*"6$#$64& 7.2L$63& .KK.+6$#.& 3J7.2*JL$1"*& 62"#.*& 652:J;5& 65.&
L"1$7J*"6$:1& :K& 37"+.6$L.& ;.:L.624G2"65.2& 65"1& 652:J;5& *:+"*& L:6$:1& .d+..%$1;& 65.&
37..%&:K&*$;56G-"3&7*"+.%&:1&2$;:2:J3&K::6$1;&M4&H* +JM$.22.&$1&?==A&i?j(&_5.&H*+JM$.22.&
-"27&%2$#.&+:1362J+63&"&2.;$:1&:K&+:162"+6.%&37"+.6$L.&"5."%&:K&"&37"+.+2"K6&"1%&.d7"1%.%&
37"+.6$L.&M.5$1%&$6`&+2."6$1;&"&kMJMM*.l&65"6&+"22$.3&65.& +2"K6&K:2-"2%&"6&"1&"2M$62"2$*4&*"2;.&
.KK.+6$#.&#.*:+$64&-5$*.&65.&$16.2$:2&2.L"$13&*:+"**4&T*"6(&_5.&37"+.+2"K6`&$1&65$3&7$+6J2.`&1.#.2&
.d+..%3&,&$1&"14&*:+"*&I:2.16^&K2"L.m&$6&$3&65.&37"+.6$L.&3J22:J1%$1;&65.&+2"K6&65"6&L:#.3(&
_5$3& :M3.2#"6$:1& .*.+62$T$.%& 65.& 65.:2.6$+"*& 7543$+3& +:LLJ1$64`& %.L:1362"6$1;& 65"6& 65.&
'$136.$1& T$.*%& .ZJ" 6 $:13& 65.L3.*#.3& +:16 "$1& 3:*J6$:13& -$65& 72:K:J1%*4& +:J16.2$16J$6$#.&
,$1.L"6$+&72:7.26$.3(
]:-.#.2`& 65.& H*+JM$.22.& L.62$+& +"22$.3& "& 3.#.2.& 7543$+"*& +:368& 65.& 362.33>.1.2;4& 6.13:2&
2.ZJ$2.%& 6:& 3:J2+.& 65.& -"27>MJMM*.& ;.:L.624& #$:*"6.3& M:65& 65.& -.",& "1%& 1J**& .1.2;4&
+:1%$6$:13& PS'e& "1%& n'eR(& 01& 72"+6$+"*& 6.2L3`& 65.& MJMM*.& %.L"1%3& k.d:6$+& L"66.2lG
L"66.2>.1.2;4& -$65& 1.;"6$#.& .1.2;4& %.13$64& "3& L."3J2.%& M4& 6$L.*$,.& :M3.2#.23(& _5.&
L";1$6J%.& :K& .d:6$+& L"66.2&2.ZJ$2.%& $1& 65.& :2$;$1"*& K:2LJ*"6$:1& $3& :K& :2%.2&3.#.2"*& 3:*"2&
L"33.3&:K&1.;"6$#.&.1.2;4`&"&ZJ"16$64&K:2&-5$+5&1:&,1:-1&7543$+"*&L.+5"1$3L&.d$363(&_5$3&
5"3&*.%&L"14&"J65:23&6:&2.;"2%&65.&-"27&%2$#.&"3&"&L"65.L"6$+"*&+J2$:3$64&2"65.2&65"1&"&
7543$+"**4&2."*$^"M*.&3:*J6$:1(
aJM3.ZJ.16&%.+"%.3& M2:J;56&$L7:26"16&2.T$1.L.163(&o"1& !.1&)2:.+,&iEj& 35:-.%&65"6&M4&
L:%$K4$1;&65.&$16.21"*&;.:L.624&:K&65.&MJMM*.`&65.&6:6"*&1.;"6$#.&.1.2;4&+:J*%&M.&2.%J+.%&
M4& L"14& :2%.23& :K& L";1$6J%.& -5$*.& 72.3.2#$1;& 65.& .d6.21"*& -"27& .KK.+6(& n"6"p 2$:& iCj&
+:1362J+6.%&"&-"27>%2$#.&;.:L.624&-$65&^.2:&.d7"13$:1`&2.*4$1;&$136."%&:1&65.&2:6"6$:1&:K&
37"6$"*& #:*JL.3& 6:& "+5$.#.& .KK.+6$#.& L:6$:1`& "1%& %.L:1362"6.%& 65"6& 65.& H*+JM$.22.&
.d7"13$:1&$3&1:6&65.&:1*4&,$1.L"6$+&7"65-"4(&):M2$+,&"1%&W"26$2.&iAj&$162:%J+.%&"&;.1.2"*&
+*"33$T$+"6$:1&K2"L.-:2,&K:2&-"27>%2$#.&37"+.6$L.3&"1%&+*"2$T$.%&65.&2.*"6$:135$7&M.6-..1&
MJMM*.& ;.:L.624`& .1.2;4& +:1%$6$:13`& "1%& 7"33.1;.2& .d7.2$.1+.(& W:36& 2.+.16*4`& I.16^& iqj&
2.7:26.%& "& +*"33& :K& 3:*$6:1& 3:*J6$:13& $1& '$136.$1& ;2"#$64& 65"6& "+5$.#.& 547.2>K"36& .KK.+6$#.&
#.*:+$6$.3&-$65&7J2.*4&7:3$6$#.&.1.2;4&%.13$6 $.3` &M2.",$1;&-5"6&5"%&M..1&"33JL.%&6:&M.&"1&
$1#$:*"M*.& M"22$.2(& S5$*.& I.16^U3& 3:*J6$:13& 2.L"$1& J1%.2& "+6$#.& 3+2J6$14& 2.;"2%$1;& 65.$2&
7543$+"*&#$"M$*$64&"1%&36"M$*$64`&65.4&5"#.& 2.:7.1.%&65.&ZJ.36$:1&:K&-5.65.2&.d :6$+&L"66.2&$3&
62J*4&$1%$37.13"M*.&K:2&-"27>%2$#.&7543$+3(
!.37$6.&65.3.&"%#"1+.3`&1:&KJ**4&3"6$3K"+6:24&2.3:*J6$:1&5"3& .L.2;.%&-$65$1&65.&36"1%"2%&
;.:L.62$+&K2"L.-:2,(&_5.&KJ1%"L.16"*&%$KT$+J*64&$3&65"6&36"1%"2%&;.1.2"*&2.*"6$#$64&62."63&
37"+.6$L.& ;.:L.624& "1%& L"66.2>.1.2;4& "3& +:J7*.%& 652:J;5& 65.& '$136.$1& T$.*%& .ZJ"6$:13`&
"1%& -$65$1& 65$3& +:J7*$1;& 362J+6J2.`& .KK.+6$#.& 3J7.2*JL$1"*& 62"137:26& "77."23& 6:& %.L"1%&
.1.2;4>+:1%$6$:1&#$:*"6$:13(&S5"6&5" 3&M..1&L$33$1;&$3&"&2.K:2LJ*"6$:1&:K&65.&72:M*.L&65"6&
.1*"2;.3&65.&;.:L.62$+&"2.1"&$1&-5$+5&-"27&%41"L$+3&6",.&7*"+.`&72:#$%$1;&1.-&%.;2..3&:K&
K2..%:L&65"6&+"1&"M3:2M&-5"6&-:J*%&:65.2-$3.&L"1$K.36&"3&.d:6$+>L"66.2&2.ZJ$2.L.163(
_5.&72.3.16&7"7.2&J1$T$.3&6-:&$1%.7.1%.16&*$1.3&:K&-:2,&65"6`&-.&"2;J.`&72:#$%.&72.+$3.*4&
3J+5&"&2.K:2LJ*"6$:1(
_5.& T$236& *$1.& :2$;$1"6.3& -$65& )."2%3*.4& iFj`& -5:& $162:%J+.%& "& 3.6& :K& 7543$+"*& $1#"2$"163&
"1+5:2.%&6:&"&6.L7:2"*&+:136"16&X
<
&Y&?&3(&r2:L&65$3&3$1;*.&%$L.13$:1KJ*&"1+5:2`&)."2%3*.4&
%.2$#.3&"&K:2+.&+:136"16&!
"
&Y	+X
<
E
&"1%&"&37"+.*$,.&2"%$J3&T$.*%&$
%
&%.3+2$M$1;&65.&62"13#.23.&
;.:L.624&:K&"&-"27&MJMM*.(&_:;.65.2&65.3.&%.T$1.&"&1"6J2"*&2.3:1"1+.&+:1%$6$:1&"6&"1;J*"2&
K2.ZJ.1+4& [
<
& Y& E\9X
<
& Y& E\& ]^(& )."2%3*.4& $%.16$T$.3& 65$3& "3& 65.& KJ1%"L.16"*& :3+$**"6$:1&
K2.ZJ.1+4&:K&"&-"27>MJMM*.&+:1T$;J2"6$:1&"1%&%.L:1362"6.3&65"6&$6&+:11.+63&N*"1+,>3+"*.&
7543$+3&6:&L"+2:3+:7$+&2.3:1"1+.&652:J;5&"&2.L"2,"M*.&%$L.13$:1*.33&$%.16 $6 4&$1#:*#$1;&
65.& N*"1+,& K:2+.(& _5.& K2"L.-:2,& $3& L$1$L"*$36& $1& $63& "33JL76$:13& MJ6& 2$+5 & $1& $63&
+:13.ZJ.1+.38&"&3$1;*.&6.L7:2"*&3+"*.&;.1.2"6.3&"&+:L7*.6.&%41"L$+"*&3,.*.6:1&K:2&MJMM*.&
:3+$**"6$:13(
_5.&3.+:1%&*$1.&:2$;$1"6.3&-$65&)*"+,-.**&iB`&@`&=j`&-5:&%.#.*:7.%&65.&VM3.2#.2>!.7.1%.16&
01K:2L"6$:1&W.62$+& PV!0W>OR(& 01& 65$3&K2"L.-:2,`& 65.& ;.:L.624& :K& 37"+.6$L.& $3& 2.+"36& $1&
6.2L3& :K& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& +::2%$1"6.3G%.;2..3& :K& K2..%:L& 65"6& .1+:%.& 65.& $1K:2L"6$:1&
+:16.16& "++.33$M*.& 6:& "1& :M3.2#.2(& N2:7.2& 6$L.& $63.*K& $3& %.T$1.%& M4& 65.& $1K:2L"6$:1"*&
+J2#"6J2.&.d7.2$.1+.%&M4&65.&:M 3.2#.2`&"1%&;2"#$6"6$:1"*&%41"L$+3&.L.2;.&K2:L&;.:%.3$+&
L:6$:1& $1& "1& $1K:2L"6$:1& L"1$K:*%(& V!0W>O& 72:#$%.3& "& 1"6J2"*& *"1;J";.& K:2& %$3+J33$1;&
:M3.2#.2>%.7.1%.16& 75.1:L.1"& "1%`& +2J+$"**4`& $162:%J+.3& ;.:L.62$+& %.;2..3&:K& K2..%:L&
M.4:1%&65:3.&:K&65.&36"1%"2%&37"+.6$L.&L.62$+(
_5.& +.162"*& 65.3$3& :K& 65$3& 7"7.2& $3& 65"6& 65.3.& 6-:& K2"L.-:2,3& L.2;.& 1"6J2"**4& "1%&
72:%J+6$#.*4(&)."2%3*.4 U3&$1#"2$"163&%.T$1.&65.&36$KK1.33&"1%&.KK.+6$#.&L"33&7"2"L.6.23&:K&"&
1:2L"*&L:%.&-$65$1&65.&V!0W>O&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&L.62$+(&_5.&-"27>MJMM*.&2.3:1"1+.&"6&E\&
]^&.L.2;.3&1:6&"3&"1&.d6.21"**4&$L7:3.%&+:1%$6$:1&MJ6&"3&"&;.:L.62$+&.$;.1K2.ZJ.1+4G"&
+J2#"6J2.&.$;.1L:%.&:K&65.&.d6.1%.%&$1K:2L"6$:1>;.:L.62$+&L"1$K:*%(&_5$3&.*$L$1"6.3&65.&
1..%& K:2& .d:6$+& L"66.2& M4& 2.$16.272.6$1;& MJMM*.& %41"L$+3& "3& ;.:%.3$+& L:6$:1& $1& "1&
.d6.1%.%& +:1T$;J2"6$:1& 37"+.& P*
%
`& &
+
R& 65"6& $1+*J%.3& M:65& 37"+.6$L.& +::2%$1"6.3& "1%&
$1K:2L"6$:1"*& %.;2..3& :K& K2..%:L(& _5.& 35$7& K:**:-3& "& ;.:%.3$+& :K& 65.& KJ**& L"1$K:*%m& 65.&
"77"2.16& .1.2;4>+:1%$6$:1& #$:*"6$:1& $3& "& 72:s.+6$:1& "26$K"+6& "2$3$1;& K2:L& 2.362$+6$1;&
"66.16$:1&6:&65.&37"+.6$L.&3JML"1$K:*%&"*:1.(
_5.& 7"7.2& $3& :2;"1$^.%& "3& K:**:-3(& a.+6$:1& E& 2.#$.-3& )."2%3*.4U3& $1#"2$"163& "1%& 65.$2&
7543$+"*& +:16.16 (& a.+6$:1& C& 3JLL"2$^.3& 65.& V!0W>O& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& L.62$+& K2"L.-:2,(&
a.+6$:1& A& .LM.%3& 65.& 2"%$J3& T$.*%& "3& "1& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& +::2%$1"6.&"1%& %.2$#.3& 65.& E\>]^&
2.3:1"1+.&K2:L&65.&;.:L.624(& a.+6$:1&q&.d6.1%3&65.&+:1362J+6$:1&6:&65.& KJ**&-"27&L.62$+&
"1%& 35$K6>#.+6:2& %41"L$+3(& a.+6$:1& F& %$3+J33.3& 65.& 7543$+"*& $16.272.6"6$:1& :K& .d6.1%.%>
+:1T$;J2"6$:1>37"+.&;.:%.3$+3&"1%&65.&.*$L$1"6$:1&:K&.d:6$+&L"66.2(&a.+6$:1&B&72.3.163&65.&
#"2$"6$:1"*& K:2LJ*"6$:1(& a.+6$:1& @& %$3+J33.3& :7.1& ZJ.36$:13& "1%& KJ6J2.& %$2.+6$:13`& "1%&
a.+6$:1&=&+:1+*J%.3(
1E+F-'%97*-.G7+!"='%)'"(7
_5.&$1#"2$"16&K2"L.-:2,&$162:%J+.%&M4&)."2%3*.4&iFj&$3&2.L"2,"M*.&K:2&$63&.+:1:L48&K2:L&"&
3$1;*.& 6.L7:2"*& "1+5:2`& $6& ;.1.2"6.3& "& +:L7*.6.& 3.6& :K& 3+"*.3& 2.*.#"16& 6:& -"27>%2$#.&
%41"L$+3(&S.&2.#$.-&65.&+:2.&%.T$1$6$:13&"1%&65.$2&7543$+"*&L:6$#"6$:1(
1EDE+H0-+H-&;$%'*+!"='%)'"(
_5.&K:J1%"6$:1"*&ZJ"16$64&$3&65.&6.L7:2"*&$1#"2$"16&X
<
&Y&?&3(&H6&T$236&.1+:J16.2`&65$3&+5:$+.&
L"4&"77."2&"2M$62"24G"1&"26$K"+6&:K&65.&a0&J1$6&3436.L(&]:-.#.2`&)."2%3*.4&"2;J.3&65"6&X
<
&
3.2#.3& "& 72.+$3.& 362J+6J2"*& 2:*.8& $6& "1+5:23& 65.& K2"L.-:2,& 6:& 65.& L"+2:3+:7$+& %:L"$1`&
72:#$%$1;&"&2.K.2.1+.&3+"*.&65"6&M2$%;.3&N*"1+,>3+"*.&ZJ"16$6$.3&P-5$+5&"2.&:K&:2%.2&?<
tAA
&3&
"1%&?<
tCq
&LR&6:&*"M:2"6:24&7543$+3(&_5.&3.*.+6$:1&:K&X
<
&Y&?&3&$3&1:6&"&+*"$L&65"6&:1.&3.+:1%&$3&
7543$+"**4& 72$#$*.;.%&$1& "1& "M3:*J6.& 3.13.`&MJ6&2"65.2& 65"6& T$d$1;& "&L"+2:3+:7$+&6.L7:2"*&
2.K.2.1+.& .1"M*.3& 65.& +:1362J+6$:1& :K& %$L.13$:1*.33& 2"6$:3& 65"6& 2.#."*& 5$%%.1& 362J+6J2"*&
2.*"6$:135$73&M.6-..1&ZJ"16JL`&2.*"6$#$36$+`&"1%&;2"#$6"6$:1"*&+:136"163(
1E1E+H0-+I$%8-+J$"7('"(
r2:L&65.&6.L7:2"*&$1#"2$"16`&)."2%3*.4&%.T$1.3&65.&K:2+.&+:136"168
013.26$1;&65.&KJ1%"L.16"*&+:136 "16 3&#&u&F(FEF&v&?<
tCA
&fw 3&"1%&,&u&E(==@&v&?<
@
&L93`&-$65& X
<
&Y&
?&3`&:1.&:M6"$138
P?R
𝐹
𝑛
=
h
𝑐 𝜏
2
0
PER
𝐹
𝑛
= 2.21022𝐸 − 42𝑁
_5$3&ZJ"16$64&5"3&65.&%$L.13$:13&:K&K:2+.&"1%&+:LM$1.3&65.&ZJ"16JL&+:136"16&#&-$65&65.&
2.*"6$#$36$+& +:136"16& ,`& 1:2L"*$^.%& M4& 65.& 3ZJ"2.& :K& 65.& 6.L7:2"*& $1#"2$"16(& 063& 7543$+"*&
$16.272.6"6$:1&$3&65"6&:K&"&ZJ"16JL>;2"#$6"6$:1"*&K:2+.&3+"*.8&$6 &$3&65.&K:2+.&"33:+$"6.%&-$65&"&
ZJ"16JL&:K&"+6$:1&%.*$#.2.%&:#.2&"&2.*"6$#$36$+&*.1;65&3+"*.&-$65$1&:1.&6.L7:2"*&7.2$:%&X
<
(&
S5$*.&!
"
&$3&.d62":2%$1"2$*4&3L"**&M4&.#.24%"4&36"1%"2%3`&$63&2:*.&$1&65.&K2"L.-:2,&$3&1:6&"3&"&
L."3J2"M*.&*"M:2"6:24&K:2+.&MJ6&"3&"&+:J7*$1;&+:136"16&65"6&3.63&65.&3+"*.&:K&-"27>MJMM*.&
%41"L$+3(
1EKE+H0-+L*'"8M3I$%8-+!9-"()(.
_5.& %..7.36& 362J+6J2"*& 2.3J*6& :K& )."2%3*.4U3& $1#"2$"16& K2"L.-:2,& $3& "& %$L.13$:1*.33&
$%.16$64&+:11.+6$1;&!
"
&6:&65.&N*"1+,&K:2+.&!
N*"1+,
&Y&,
A
9-&u&?(E?<&v&?<
AA
&n&"1%&65.&N*"1+,& 6$L.&
.
/
&Y&xP-9,
q
R&u&q(C=?&v&?<
tAA
&38
nJL.2$+"*& #.2$T $+"6$:1& $3& 362"$;56K:2-"2%(& V1.& +:L7J6.3&
(& _5.& $%.16$64& 5:*%3& .d"+ 6*4`&
$1%.7.1%.16& :K& 65.& 1JL.2$+"*& #"*J.3& :K& 65.& KJ1%"L.16"*& +:136"163(& 063& 3$;1$T$+"1+.& $3&
72:K:J1%8&$6&+:11.+63&65.&2"6$:&:K&"&ZJ"16JL>;2"#$6"6$:1"*&K:2+.&6:&65.&N*"1+,&K:2+.&-$65&65.&
2"6$:&:K&"&L"+2:3+:7$+&6$L.&6:&65.&N*"1+,&6$L.&652:J;5&.d"+6*4&65.&K"+6:2&E\`&3J;;.36$1;&"&
%..7&2.3:1"1+.&362J+6J2.&*$1,$1;&65.&ZJ"16JL>;2"#$6"6$:1"*&"1%&L"+2:3+:7$+&%:L"$13(
1ENE+H0-+O'(>%'*+I%-P>-"8.
_5.&"1;J*"2&K2.ZJ.1+4&65"6&.L.2;.3&K2:L&65.&$1#"2$"16&362J+6J2.&$38
PCR
𝐹
𝑛
𝐹
𝑃𝑙𝑎𝑛𝑐𝑘
⋅
𝜏
2
0
𝑡
2
𝑃
= 2𝜋
h
𝑐 𝜏
2
0
⋅
𝐺
𝑐
4
⋅
𝜏
2
0
𝑡
2
𝑃
=
h
𝑐 𝜏
2
0
⋅
𝐺
𝑐
4
⋅ 𝜏
2
0
⋅
𝑐
5
ℏ𝐺
=
h
𝑐
5
⋅
𝑐
5
ℏ
= h ⋅
2𝜋
h
= 2𝜋
PAR
𝜔
0
= 2𝜋/𝜏
0
= 2𝜋!rad/s
+:22.37:1%$1;&6:&"&7.2$:%&0&Y&?&3&"1%&"1&:2%$1"24&K2.ZJ.1+4&1&Y&?&]^(&)."2%3*.4&$%.16$T$.3&
65$3& "3& 65.& k5."26M."6l& :K& 65.& -"27>MJMM*.& 2.3:1"1+.G65.& +5"2"+6.2$36$+& :3+$**"6$:1&
K2.ZJ.1+4& "6& -5$+5& "& -"27>MJMM*.& +:1T$;J2"6$:1& 1"6J2"**4& #$M2"6.3(& _5.& .L.2;.1+.& :K& "&
L"+2:3+:7$+&K2.ZJ.1+4& K2:L& KJ1%"L.16"*& +:136"163& $3& $63.*K& 1:6.-:26548& $6& 3J;;.363& 65"6&
-"27>MJMM*.&%41"L$+3&"2.&;:#.21.%&1:6&M4&N*"1+,>3+"*.&:3+$**"6$:13&MJ6&M4&"&L"+2:3+:7$+&
1:2L"*&L:%.&-5:3.&.d$36.1+.&$3&;J"2"16..%&M4&65.&$1#"2$"16&362J+6J2.(
KE+H0-+Q<!A3R+!"#$%&'()$"'*+A-(%)8
_5.& VM3.2#.2>!.7.1%.16& 01K:2L"6$:1& W.62$+& PV!0W>OR`& %.#.*:7.%& M4& )*"+,-.**& iB`& @j`&
72:#$%.3& 65.& ;.:L.62$+& "2.1"& -$65$1& -5$+5& )."2%3*.4U3& $1#"2$"163& "+ZJ$2.& "& 1"6J2"*&
$16.272.6"6$:1(&S.&72.3.16&65.&K2"L.-:2,&3436.L"6$+"**4(
KEDE+I>"9'&-"('*+L$7(>*'(-
_5.&+.162"*&7:36J*"6.&:K&V!0W>O&$3&65"6& 65.&;.:L.624&:K&37"+.6$L.&+"1&M.&2.+"36&$1&6.2L3&:K&
$1K:2L"6$:1"*&+::2%$1"6.3&&
+
`&-5.2.&65.&$1%.d&+&2J13&:#.2&65.& %$L.13$:13&:K&"1&$1K:2L"6$:1&
L"1$K:*%(& 01& 65$3& 2.K:2LJ*"6$:1`& 72:7.2& 6$L.& $3& %.T$1.%& 1:6& M4& 65.& 36"1%"2%& 37"+.6$L.&
L.62$+&"*:1.&MJ6&M4&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&+J2#"6J2.&.d7.2$.1+.%&M4&"1&:M3.2#.28
-5.2.& 2
+3
P&R& $3& 65.& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& L.62$+& 6.13:2`& "& 3L::65`& 34LL.62$+`& 1:1>%.;.1.2"6.&
2"1,>E& 6.13:2& T$.*%& :1& 65.& $1K:2L"6$:1& L"1$K:*%(& _5$3& L.62$+& $3& "& KJ1+6$:1& :K& 65.&
$1K:2L"6$:1"*&+::2%$1"6.3&65.L3.*#.3`&L",$1;&65.&;.:L.624&KJ**4&%41"L$+"*(
KE1E+L0.7)8'*+!"(-%;%-('()$"
'"+5&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&+::2%$1"6.&&
+
&2.72.3.163&"&%$36$1+6&+5"11.*&:K&$1K:2L"6$:1&"++.33$M*.&6:&
"1& :M3.2#.2(& 01& 65.& 3$L7*.36& 2."*$^"6$:1`& 65.& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& +::2%$1"6.3& L"4& M.& $%.16$T$.%&
-$65&65.&36"1%"2%&37"+.6$L.&+::2%$1"6.3&*
%
`&"1%& 2
+3
&2.%J+.3&6:& 65.&37"+.6$L.&L.62$+&2
%4
(&
]:-.#.2`& 65.& V!0W>O& K2"L.-:2,& $3& L:2.& ;.1.2"*8& $6& 7.2L$63& "%%$6$:1"*& $1K:2L"6$:1"*&
'τ
E
= 2
+3
(&) '&
+
'&
3
PqR
%.;2..3&:K&K2..%:L&M.4:1%&65.&K:J2& 37"+.6$L.& %$L.13$:13(& _5.& L.62$+& 2
+3
& .1+:%.3& 5:-&
+5"1;.3& $1& $1K:2L"6$:1& +:16.16& "*:1;& %$KK.2.16& +5"11.*3& +:162$MJ6.& 6:& 65.& :M3.2#.2U3&
.d7.2$.1+.%& 72:7.2&6$L.(& e2J+$"**4`& 65$3& $3& :M3.2#.2>%.7.1%.16G%$KK.2.16&:M3.2#.23& -$65&
%$KK.2.16& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& "++.33& .d7.2$.1+.& %$KK.2.16& .KK.+6$#.& ;.:L.62$.3(& _5$3& :M3.2#.2>
%.7.1%.1+.&$3&1:6&"&%.K.+6&MJ6&"&K."6J2.8&$6&2.T*.+63&65.&7543$+"*&2."*$64&65"6&:M3.2#.23&-$65&
%$KK.2.16&L."3J2.L.16&+"7"M$*$6$.3&:2&%$KK.2.16&+"J3"*&"++.33&6:&2.;$:13&:K&37"+.6$L.&-$**`&$1&
;.1.2"*`&%.3+2$M.&%$KK.2.16&.KK.+6$#.&%41"L$+3(
_5.& V!0W>O& K2"L.-:2,& 65.2.K:2.& 72:#$%.3& "& 1"6J2"*& ;.1.2"*$^"6$:1& :K& 65.& .ZJ$#"*.1+.&
72$1+$7*.8&sJ36&"3&;.1.2"*& 2.*"6$#$64&$%.16$T$.3&;2"#$6"6$:1"*&.KK.+63&-$65&37"+.6$L.& +J2#"6J2.`&
V!0W>O&$%.16$T$.3&65.&6:6"*$64&:K&"1&:M3.2#.2U3&%41"L$+"*&.d7.2$.1+.&-$65&+J2#"6J2.&$1&"1&
$1K:2L"6$:1&L"1$K:*%&65"6&L"4&M.&*"2;.2&65"1&37"+.6$L.&$63.*K(
KEKE+H0-+!"#$%&'()$"'*+,-$9-7)8+?P>'()$"
H1& :M3.2#.2& $1& K2..& K"**G.d7.2$.1+$1;& 1:& 1:1>;2"#$6"6$:1"*& K:2+.3GK:**:-3& ;.:%.3$+3& :K&
65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&L.62$+8
-5.2.&y
+
3,
&"2.&65.&e52$36:KK.*&34LM:*3&:K&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&L.62$+&2
+3
P&R(&_5$3&.ZJ"6$:1&$3&
65.&%$2.+6&"1"*:;J.&:K&65.&;.:%.3$+&.ZJ"6$:1&$1&;.1.2"*&2.*"6$#$64`&MJ6&1:-&;:#.213&L:6$:1&
$1&65.&KJ**&$1K:2L"6$:1&L"1$K:*%(
KENE+!"#$%&'()$"'*+!"-%()'*+I$%8-
S5.1&"1&:M3.2#.2&%.#$"6.3&K2:L&;.:%.3$+&L:6$:1GK:2&$136"1+.`&%J .&6:&"1&"77*$.%&K:2+.&:2&
"&+:1362"$16G65.&+:#"2$"16&"++.*.2"6$:1&$1&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1&L"1$K:*%&$3&1:1^.2:8
5
E
&
+
5X
E
= '
E
&
+
'X
E
+ Γ
+
3,
'&
3
'X '&
,
'X = 0
PFR
!
+
$1.26$"
= 5
E
&
+
5X
E
= '
E
&
+
'X
E
+ Γ
+
3,
'&
3
'X '&
,
'X
PBR
_5$3&$3&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&"1"*:;J.&:K& 65.&K:J2>"++.*.2"6$:1&$1&;.1.2"*&2.*"6$#$64(&06&L."3J2.3&
65.&K"$*J2.&:K&"1&:M3.2#.2U3&-:2*%*$1.&6:&M.&"&;.:%.3$+&:K&65.&KJ**&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&;.:L.624(
KESE+J>%='(>%-+?)T-"='*>-+!"(-%;%-('()$"
_5.&z$.L"11&+J2#"6J2.&6.13:2&$
+
3,'
&:K&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&L.62$+&7:33.33.3&.$;.1#"*J.3&65"6&
+:22.37:1%&6:&1"6J2"*&:3+$**"6$:1&K2.ZJ.1+$.3&:K&65.&;.:L.624(&01&65.&+:16.d6&:K&65.&72.3.16&
-:2,`&)."2%3*.4U3&k6.L7:2"*&2.3$36"1+.lG65.&6.1%.1+4&:K&65.&-"27>MJMM*.&+:1T$;J2"6$:1&6:&
:3+$**"6.&"6&[
<
GM.+:L.3&$%.16$T$.%&-$65&"&+J2#"6J2.&.$;.1#"*J.&:K&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&L.62$+(&
_5$3& $%.16$T$+"6$:1& $3& 65.& +.162"*& M2$%;.& M.6-..1& 65.& 6-:& K2"L.-:2,3(& _5.& 2.3:1"1+.&
K2.ZJ.1+4&$3&1:6&$L7:3.%&K2:L&:J63$%.m&$6&$3&"&72:7.264&:K&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&;.:L.624&$63.*K(&
_5.& +J2#"6J2.& :K& 65.& $1K:2L"6$:1& L"1$K:*%& $1& 65.& %$2.+6$:13& +:22.37:1%$1;& 6:& MJMM*.&
%41"L$+3&%.6.2L$1.3&65.&36$KK1.33&:K&65.&2.36:2$1;&K:2+.&65"6&72:%J+.3&:3+$**"6$:13`&"1%&65.&
.$;.1#"*J.&37.+62JL&:K&65$3&+J2#"6J2.&6.13:2&%$2.+6*4&4$.*%3&65.&1:2L"*>L:%.&K2.ZJ.1+$.3(
NE+?&C-99)"T+(0-+6'9)>7+I)-*9
_5$3&3.+6$:1&72.3.163&65.&+.16 2"*&6.+51$+"*&2.3J*6&:K&65.&7"7.28&65.&%.2$#"6$:1&:K&65.&E\>]^&
-"27>MJMM*.&2.3:1"1+.&K2:L&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&;.:L.624(&S.&72:+..%&36.7&M4&36.7`&L",$1;&
"**&"33JL76$:13&.d7*$+$6(
NEDE+H0-+6'9)>7+I)-*9
)."2%3*.4U3& 2"%$J3& T$.*%& $
%
& $3& "& 37"+.*$,.& K:J2>#.+6:2& T$.*%& %.T$1.%& :1& 65.& 37"+.6$L.&
L"1$K:*%`&3JMs.+6&6:&6-:&+:1%$6$:13(&r$236`&$6&$3&:265:;:1"*&6:&65.&:M3.2#.2U3&K:J2>#.*:+$64&6
%
8
a.+:1%`&$63&3ZJ"2.%&1:2L&;$#.3&65.&3ZJ"2.&:K&65.&MJMM*.&2"%$J3&7
)
8
$
%
6
%
= 0
P@R
−$
%
$
%
= 7
)
E
P=R
_5.& 1.;"6$#.& 3$;1& "2$3.3& M.+"J3.& $
%
& $3& 37"+.*$,.& $1& "& L.62$+& -$65& 3$;1" 6J2.& Pt`& c`& c`& cR(&
_:;.65.2`& 65.3.& +:1%$6$:13& 37.+$K4& $
%
& "3& "& 62"13#.23.& ;.:L.62$+& %.3+2$76:2& :K& 65.& -"27&
MJMM*.8& $6& 7:$163& 2"%$"**4& :J6-"2%& K2:L& 65.& MJMM*.& +.16.2& $1& 65.& 37"6$"*& 547.23J2K"+.&
:265:;:1"*&6:&65.&:M3.2#.2U3&-:2*%*$1.`&"1%&$63&L";1$6J%.&.1+:%.3& 65.&MJMM*.&2"%$J3(
NE1E+L%$&$()$"+($+'"+!"#$%&'()$"'*+J$$% 9)"'(-
_5.& ,.4& 36.7& $1& J1$K4$1;& 65.& 6-:& K2"L.-:2,3& $3& 6:& 72:L:6.& 65.& ;.:L.62$+& $1K:2L"6$:1&
+:16"$1.%&$1&$
%
&6:&"1&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&+::2%$1"6.&-$65$1&65.&V!0W>O&L"1$K:*%(&S.&%.T$1.8
-5.2.&!&$3&"&3L::65`&L:1:6:1$+&KJ1+6$:1&L"77$1;&65.&;.:L.62$+&2"%$J3&$1K:2L"6$:1&$16:&
65.&$1K:2L"6$:1&L"1$K:*%(&_5.&3$L7*.36&"1%&L:36&1"6J2"*&+5:$+.&$3&!P*R&Y&xPt*R&Y&7
)
`&-5$+5&
$%.16$T$.3& 65.& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& +::2%$1"6.& %$2.+6*4& -$65& 65.& MJMM*.& 2"%$J3(& ]:-.#.2`& 65.&
K2"L.-:2,&$3&;.1.2"*&"1%&"77*$.3&6:&"14&3L::65&L:1:6:1$+& !(&_5.&+5:$+.&:K&!&"L:J163&6:&"&
+5:$+.&:K&+::2%$1"6.3&:1&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1&L"1$K:*%G"&;"J;.&K2..%:L&65"6&%:.3&1:6&"KK.+6&
7543$+"*&72.%$+6$:13(
NEKE+H0-+?@(-"9-9+A-(%)8
S$65&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&+::2%$1"6.&&
$
& %.T$1.%`&-.&.d6.1%&65.&72:7.2>6$L.&$16.2#"*&6:&$1+*J%.&
"1&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&+:L7:1.16(&_5.&6:6"*&72:7.2&6$L.&.d7.2$.1+.%&M4&65.&:M3.2#.2&1:-&2."%38
-5.2.& 'X
7543
E
& $3& 65.& 36"1%"2%& 7543$+"*& 72:7.2& 6$L.& K2:L& 65.& 37"+.6$L.& L.62$+`& {& $3& "&
+:J7*$1;& *.1;65& 3+"*.`& "1%& 2
$$
& Y& {
E
& $3& 65.& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& L.62$+& +:L7:1.16& "*:1;& 65.& &
$
&
%$2.+6$:1(& _5.& +:J7*$1;& *.1;65& {& 3.63& 65.& 3+"*.& "6& -5$+5& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& %41"L$+3& M.+:L.&
3$;1$T$+"16&2.*"6$# .&6:&37"+.6$L.&%41"L$+3(&S5.1&{&|&<`&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&3.+6:2&%.+:J7*.3&
&
$
= !($
%
$
%
)
P?<R
'τ
6:6"*
E
= 'τ
7543
E
+ ℓ
E
('&
$
)
E
P??R
"1%&36"1%"2%&;.1.2"*&2.*"6$#$64&$3& 2.+:#.2.%(&S5.1& {&$3&T$1$6.`&65.&:M3.2#.2U3&72:7.2>6$L.&
.d7.2$.1+.&$3&.12$+5.%&M4&65.&%41"L$+"*&.# :*J6$:1&:K&65.&MJMM*.U3&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&+:16.16(
NENE+U&'**+Q78)**'()$"7+'"9+(0-+6-7$"'"8-+<-%)='()$"
S.&1:-&+:13$%.2&3L"**&:3+$**"6$:13&:K&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&+::2%$1"6.&"M:J6&"1&.ZJ$*$M2$JL&
#"*J.(&S2$6.8
&
$
&Y&&
$
P<R
&c&b&
$
-5.2.& &
$
P<R
& $3& 65.& .ZJ$*$M2$JL& 2"%$J3& "1%& b&
$
& $3& "& 3L"**& 7.26J2M"6$:1(& S.& $162:%J+.& "&
2.36:2$1;&7:6.16$"*8
_5.&7543$+"*&:2$;$1&:K&65$3&7:6.16$"*&$3&65.&+J2#"6J2.&:K&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&L.62$+&$1&65.&&
$
&
%$2.+6$:18& 1."2& 65.& .ZJ$*$M2$JL`& 65.& ;.:%.3$+& %.#$"6$:1& .ZJ"6$:1& $1& 65.& $1K:2L"6$:1&
L"1$K:*%&72:%J+.3&"&5"2L:1$+&2.36:2$1;&K:2+.&-$65& 36$KK1.33&8 &72:7:26$:1"*&6:&65.&3.+6$:1"*&
+J2#"6J2.(& _5.& 'J*.2>I";2"1;.& .ZJ"6$:1& %.2$#.%&K2:L& 65.& .d6.1%.%& L.62$+& P??R& -$65& 65.&
7:6.16$"*&P?ER&4$.*%38
-5.2.& [
<
E
& Y& 89P{& 9
.KK
R`& -$65& 9
.KK
& M.$1;& 65.& .KK.+6$#.& $1.26$"*& L"33& "33:+$"6.%& -$65& 65.&
$1K:2L"6$:1"*&+::2%$1"6.(&'ZJ"6$:1&P?CR&$3&65.&.ZJ"6$:1&:K&"&3$L7*.&5"2L:1$+&:3+$**"6:2&"6&
"1;J*"2&K2.ZJ.1+4&[
<
(&_5$3&$3&65.&-"27>MJMM*.&2.3:1"1+.8&3L"**&7.26J2M"6$:13&:K&65.&MJMM*.&
2"%$J3&:3+$**"6.&5"2L:1$+"**4&"6&65.&1"6J2"*&K2.ZJ.1+4&:K&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&;.:L.624(
NESE+A'(80)"T+($+F-'%97*-.G7+!"='%)'"(7
_5.&+:11.+6$:1&6:&)."2%3*.4U3&K2"L.-:2,&$3&L"%.&M4&3.66$1;&[
<
&Y&E\&2"%93&"1%&$%.16$K4$1;&
65.&36$KK1.33&"3&8&Y&!
"
9{(&_5$3&4$.*%3&65.&L"6+5$1;&+:1%$6$:18
: = ?E 8 (δ&
$
)
E
P?ER
'
E
Pb&
$
R'X
E
+ ω
<
E
δ&
$
= 0
P?CR
nJL.2$+"**48
_5$3& 2.3J*6& $3& 65.& .d"+6& M2$%;.& M.6-..1& )."2%3*.4U3& 7543$+"*& +:136"163& "1%& 65.& V!0W>O&
;.:L.624(& _5.& 72:%J+6& {& v& 9
.KK
& 5"3& %$L.13$:13& :K& "1;J*"2& L:L.16JL& %$#$%.%& M4& E\(&
01%..%`&:1.&+"1&#.2$K4&65"6	P+A\
E
R&Y&9+PE\R(&_5$3&+:11.+63&65.&-"27>MJMM*.&2.3:1"1+.&
6:& KJ1%"L.16"*&ZJ"16JL>;2"#$6"6$:1"*&3+"*.38& 65.& 72:%J+6&:K& 65.&+:J7*$1;&*.1;65& "1%& 65.&
.KK.+6$#.& $1.26$"*& L"33& :K& 65.& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& %.;2..& :K& K2..%:L& $3& 72.+$3.*4& 9+PE\R`& "&
ZJ"16$64&MJ$*6&.16$2.*4&K2:L&ZJ"16JL&PR&"1%&2.*"6$#$36$+&P,R&+:136"163(&_5.&"77."2"1+.&:K&
65$3&+:LM$1"6$:1&$3&1:6&"++$%.16"*m&$6&2.T*.+63&65.&K"+6&65"6&65.&2.3:1"1+.&K2.ZJ.1+4&[
<
&Y&E\&
]^&$3&65.&J1$ZJ.&#"*J.&65"6&5"2L:1$^.3&)."2%3*.4U3&L"+2:3+:7$+&$1#"2$"163&-$65&65.&N*"1+,>
3+"*.&362J+6J2.&.1+:%.%&$1&65.&V!0W>O&+J2#"6J2.(
SE+:'%;3A-(%)8+'"9+U0)#(3V-8($%+<."'&)87
]"#$1;&%.2$#.%&65.&2.3:1"1+.&K2:L&65.&2"%$J3&T$.*%`&-.&1:-&.d6.1%&65.&+:1362J+6$:1&6:&65.&
KJ**&-"27&L.62$+`&K:+J3$1;&:1&65.&35$K6&#.+6:2&65"6&.1+:%.3&65.&MJMM*.U3&.KK.+6$#.&#.*:+$64(
SEDE+H0-+B*8>C)-%%-3H.;-+:'%;+A-(%)8
_5.&36"1%"2%&H*+JM$.22.&L.62$+&i?j&6",.3&65.&K:2L8
P?AR
ℓ × 𝑚
𝑒𝑓𝑓
=
𝐹
𝑛
𝜔
2
0
=
h
𝑐 ⋅ 4𝜋
2
P?qR
ℓ × 𝑚
𝑒𝑓𝑓
=
h
𝑐 ⋅ 4𝜋
2
=
6.626 × 10
−34
(
2.998 × 10
8
)
4𝜋
2
= 5.59835𝐸 − 44𝑘𝑔 ⋅ 𝑚
';
E
= −,
E
'.
E
+ ('* − <
;
(.) 1(7
;
) '.)
E
+ '=
E
+ '>
E
P?FR
-5.2.&<
;
P.R&$3&65.&#.*:+$64&:K&65.&MJMM*.&+.16.2&"*:1;&65.&*>"d$3`&1P7
;
R&$3&65.&35"7$1;&KJ1+6$:1&
3"6$3K4$1;&1&Y&?&$13$%.&65.&MJMM*.&"1%&1&Y&<&:J63$%.`&"1%&7
;
&$3&65.&'J+*$%."1&%$36"1+.& K2:L&65.&
MJMM*.&+.16.2&$1&65.&+:L:#$1;&K2"L.(&_5$3&L.62$+&%.3+2$M.3&"&2.;$:1&:K&T*"6&37"+.6$L.&P6 5.&
MJMM*.&$16.2$:2R&+"22$.%&"*:1;&M4&"&%$36:26$:1&:K&65.&3J22:J1%$1;&;.:L.624(
SE1E+B<A+<-8$&;$7)()$"+'"9+(0-+U0)#(+V-8($%
01& 65.& H21:-$66>!.3.2>W$31.2& PH!WR& %.+:L7:3$6$:1& i?<j`& 65.& L.62$+& P?FR& 5"3& *"73.&
KJ1+6$:1&(&Y&,&P:2&(&Y&?&$1&J1$63&-5.2 .&,&Y&?R&"1%&35$K6&#.+6:28
(
)
&Y&t<
;
P.R&1P7
;
R&b
)
*
_5.&35$K6&#.+6:2&.1+:%.3&65.&.KK.+6$#.&#.*:+$64&:K&65.&MJMM*.8&$6&$3&65.&2"6.&"6&-5$+5&37"6$"*&
+::2%$1"6.3& "2.& %2";;.%& M4& 65.& -"27& ;.:L.624(& _5.& *"73.& M.$1;& J1$64& $13$%.& 65.& MJMM*.&
.13J2.3&65"6&72:7.2&6$L.&K:2&65.&:++J7"16&T*:-3&"6&65.&3"L.&2"6.&"3&+::2%$1"6.&6$L.G65.&
7"33.1;.2&.d7.2$.1+.3&1:&6$L.&%$*"6$:1(
SEKE+!"#$%&'()$"'*+J$$%9)"'(-+#$%+(0-+F>CC*-
)4& "1"*:;4& -$65& 65.& 2"%$J3& T$.*%`& -.& %.T$1.&"1& $1K:2L"6$:1"*&+::2%$1"6.& K:2&65.&MJMM*.U3&
#.*:+$64&72:T$*.8
_5$3&KJ1+6$:1"*&.1+:%.3&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&+:16.16&:K&65.&MJMM*.U3&#.*:+$64&72:T$*.G$6&L"73&
65.& KJ**& 37"6$"*& +:1T$;J2"6$:1& :K& 65.& 35$K6& #.+6:2& $16:& "& 3$1;*.& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& %.;2..& :K&
K2..%:L(&_5.&72.+$3.&K:2L&:K&65$3&KJ1+6$:1"*&%.7.1%3&:1&65.&+5:$+.&:K&$1K:2L"6$:1&L."3J2.`&
MJ6&65.&.33.16$"*&7:$16&$3&65"6&65.&MJMM*.U3&#.*:+$64&72:T$*.&$3&72:L:6.%&K2:L&"&;.:L.62$+&
T$.*%&:1&37"+.6$L.&6:&"&+::2%$1"6.&:1&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1&L"1$K:*%(
SENE+?@(-"9-9+!"#$%&'()$"'*+A-(%)8
_5.& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& L.62$+& $3& 1:-& .d6.1%.%& 6:& $1+*J%.& M:65& 65.& 2"%$J3& "1%& MJMM*.&
+::2%$1"6.38
&
?
= &
?
[(
)
(@, .)]
P?BR
-5.2.& }& $3& "& 3.+:1%& +:J7*$1;& 3+"*.& K:2& 65.& MJMM*.& %.;2..& :K& K2..%:L`& "1%& 65.& .**$73$3&
$1%$+"6.3& 7:6.16$"*& +2:33>6.2L3& "1%& "%%$6$:1"*& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& +::2%$1"6.3(& _5.& .d6.1%.%&
L.62$+& 1:-& %.3+2$M.3& "& L"1$K:*%& -$65& "6& *."36& 3$d& %$L.13$:138& K:J2& 37"+.6$L.& 7*J3& P"6&
L$1$LJLR&6-:&$1K:2L"6$:1"*(
SESE+F>CC*-+6-7$"'"8-
aL"**&:3+$**"6$:13&:K&65.&MJMM*.&+::2%$1"6.&"M:J6&.ZJ$*$M2$JL`&&
?
&Y&&
?
P<R
&c&b&
?
`&:M.48
_5$3&$3&65.&;.:L.62$+&:2$;$1&:K&65.&-"27>MJMM*.&2.3:1"1+.&"3&"77*$.%&6:&65.&#.*:+$64&72:T$*.(&
):65& 65.& 2"%$J3& T$.*%& "1%& 65.& MJMM*.& #.*:+$64& 72:T$*.& :3+$**"6.& "6& 65.& 3"L.& KJ1%"L.16"*&
K2.ZJ.1+4&[
<
&Y&E\&]^(&_5$3&J1$#.23"*$64&$3& 1:6&"&+:$1+$%.1+.G$6&2.T*.+63&65.&K"+6&65"6&[
<
&$3&"&
+J2#"6J2.&.$;.1#"*J.&:K&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&L.62$+&65"6&;:#.213&"**&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&%.;2..3&:K&
K2..%:L&+:J7*.%&6:&65.&-"27&;.:L.624(&_5.&MJMM*.&2.3:1"1+.&$3&"&;.:L.62$+&72:7.264&:K&
65.&$1K:2L"6$:1&L"1$K:*%`&1:6&"&L"6.2$"*&72:7.264&:K&"14&.d :6$+&3JM36"1+.(& n:&.d:6$+&L"66.2&
$3& 1..%.%& M.+"J3.& 65.& %41"L$+3& "2.& ;:#.21.%& M4& $1K:2L"6$:1& ;.:L.624`& 1:6& M4& 362.33>
.1.2;4(&_5.&.KK.+6$#.&k36$KK1.33l&65"6&72:%J+.3&65.&:3+$**"6 $:1&"2$3.3&K2:L&65.&+J2#"6J2.&:K&
65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&L.62$+`&-5$+5&$3&"&;.:L.62$+&%"6JL&2"65.2&65"1&"&L"66.2>.1.2;4&3:J2+.(
WE+<%$;;)"T+F-*$X+U;'8-()&-Y+?@(-"9-9+,-$9-7)87+'"9+?@$()83A'((-%+
?*)&)"'()$"
_5$3&3.+6$:1&72.3.163& 65.&+:1+.76J"*&5."26& :K& 65.& 7"7.28&65.&L.+5"1$3L& M4&-5$+5& .d:6$+&
L"66.2& $3& .*$L$1"6.%& K2:L& -"27>%2$#.& 7543$+3& 652:J;5& 65.& .1*"2;.L.16& :K& 65.& ;.:L.62$+&
"2.1"(
'τ
E
= 'τ
7543
E
+ ℓ
E
('&
$
)
E
+ Λ
E
('&
?
)
E
+ ···
P?@R
'
E
Pb&
?
R'X
E
+ ω
<
E
δ&
?
= 0
P?=R
WEDE+HX$+L%$;-%3H)&-+J$"(%)C>()$"7
_5.& 6:6"*& 72:7.2>6$L.& $16.2#"*& %.+:L7:3.3& $16:& "& 7543$+"*& P37"+.6$L.R& 7"26& "1%& "1&
$1K:2L"6$:1"*&7"268
_5.&6:6"*&72:7.2&6$L.&$38
WE1E+,-$9-7)8+A$()$"+)"+(0-+?@(-"9-9+U;'8-
_5.&37"+.+2"K6&K:**:-3&"&;.:%.3$+&$1&65.&.d6.1%.%&+:1T$;J2"6$:1&37"+.&P*
%
`&&
+
RG1:6&L.2.*4&
$1&65.&37"+.6$L.&3JML"1$K:*%&*
%
(&_5$3&$3&65.&,.4&$13$;56(&_5.&;.:%.3$+&.ZJ"6$:1&$1&65.&KJ**&
37"+.& %.6.2L$1.3& M:65& 65.& 37"+.6$L.& 62"s.+6:24& "1%& 65.& .#:*J6$:1& :K& 65.& $1K:2L"6$:1"*&
+::2%$1"6.3& 3$LJ*6"1.:J3*4(& S5"6& "77."23`& K2:L& 65.& 37"+.6$L.& 7.237.+6$#.& "*:1.`& "3& "&
62"s.+6:24& 2.ZJ$2$1;& .d:6$+& L"66.2& 6:& 3:J2+.& $3& 2.#."*.%`& $1& 65.& KJ**& .d6.1%.%& 37"+.`& "3& "&
7.2K.+6*4&:2%$1"24&;.:%.3$+(
WEKE+B;;'%-"(+U>;-%3?#Z)8)-"8.
01&36"1%"2%&;.1.2"*&2.*"6$#$64`&"+5$.#$1;&.KK.+6$#.&3J7.2*JL$1"*& 62"#.*&2.ZJ$2.3& 65.&362.33>
.1.2;4&6.13:2&0
%4
&6:&#$:*"6.&65.&-.",&.1.2;4&+:1%$6 $:18&0
%4
&6
%
&6
4
&~&<&K:2&3:L.&6$L.*$,.&6
%
(&
_5$3&$3&65.&.d:6$+>L"66.2&2.ZJ$2.L.16(&01&65.&.d6.1%.%&K2"L.-:2,`&65.&35$7U3&-:2*%*$1.&$3&"&
;.:%.3$+&:K&65.&KJ**&P37"+.6$L.&c&$1K:2L"6$:1R&L"1$K:*%(&_5.&.KK.+6$#.&362.33>.1.2;4&6.13:2&
+:L7J6.%& M4& 72:s.+6$1;& 65.& KJ**& %41"L$+3& :16:& 65.& 37"+.6$L.& 3JML"1$K:*%& "+ZJ$2.3&
+:162$MJ6$:13&K2:L&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&3.+6:2(&_5.3.&+:162$MJ6$:13&+"1&5"#.&65.&k-2:1;&3$;1l&
'τ
7543
E
= −?,
E
2
%4
'*
%
'*
4
PE<R
'τ
$1K:
E
= 2
+3
(&) '&
+
'&
3
PE?R
'τ
6:6"*
E
= 'τ
7543
E
+ 'τ
$1K:
E
PEER
K2:L&65.&37"+.6$L.&7.237.+6$#.GL$L$+,$1;&.d:6$+&L"66.2G.#.1&65:J;5&65.&KJ**&%41"L$+3&
"2.&7.2K.+6*4&-.**>M.5"#.%&$1&65.&.d6.1%.%&37"+.(&_5.&"77"2.16&.1.2;4>+:1%$6$:1&#$:*"6$:1&
$3&"1&"26$K"+6&:K&%$L.13$:1"*&2.%J+6$:1`&1:6&"&7543$+"*&7"65:*:;4(
H& J3.KJ*& "1"*:;4& +*"2$T$.3& 65.& L.+5"1$3L(& e:13$%.2& "& M"**& 2:**$1;& :1& "& 6-:>%$L.13$:1"*&
3J2K"+.&65"6&+:16"$13&"&6J11.*&7"33$1;&652:J;5&65.&$16.2$:2&:K&"&5$**(&H1&:M3.2#.2&2.362$+6.%&
6:&65.&3J2K"+.&3..3&65.&M"**&%$3"77."2&K2:L&:1.&3$%.&:K&65.&5$**&"1%&2."77."2&:1&65.&:6 5.2`&
62"#.23$1;&"&%$36"1+.&65"6&-:J*%&2.ZJ$2.&3J7.2*JL$1"*&37..%&$K&65.&M"**&-.2.&+:1362"$1.%&6:&
65.&3J2K"+.(&01& 652..&%$L.13$:13`&65.& M"**&3$L7*4&2:**.%&652:J;5&65.&6J11.*&"6&3JM*JL$1"*&
37..%(& _5.& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& %$L.13$:13& :K& 65.& V!0W>O& L"1$K:*%& "2.& 65.& k6J11.*l& 652:J;5&
-5$+5&65.&-"27&MJMM*.&L:#.38&65.&"77"2.16*4&.d:6$+&62"s.+6:24&$1&37"+.6$L.&$3&65.&35"%:-&
:K&"&7.2K.+6*4&:2%$1"24&;.:%.3$+&$1&65.&*"2;.2&L"1$K:*%(
WENE+J'>7'*)(.+L%-7-%='()$"
I:+"*&+"J3"* $6 4& $3&72.3.2#.%&M.+"J3.&65.& .d6.1%.%&;.:%.3$+&.ZJ"6$:1&$3&547.2M:*$+&$1& 65.&
KJ**&+:1T$;J2"6$:1&37"+.(&_5.&+5"2"+6.2$36$+&37..%3&:K&65.&.d6.1%.%&3436.L&%:&1:6&.d+..%&,&
$1&"14&*:+"*&K2"L.&:K&65.&KJ**&L"1$K:*%(&n:&+*:3.%&6$L.*$,.&+J2#.3&"2.&+2."6.%&$1&65.&.d6.1%.%&
37"+.`& .#.1& 65:J;5& 65.& 37"+.6$L.& 72:s.+6$:1& :K& 65.& 62"s.+6:24& L"4& "77."2& 6:& M.&
3J7.2*JL$1"*(&_5.&"77"2.16&3J7.2*JL$1"*&L:6$:1&$3&362$+6*4&"&72:s.+6$:1&"26$K"+68&65.&35$7&
1.#.2& .d+..%3& ,& $1& "14& *:+"*& I:2.16^& K2"L.`& -5.65.2& %.T$1.%& $1& 37"+.6$L.& :2& $1& 65.& KJ**&
.d6.1%.%&L"1$K:*%(
[E+V'%)'()$"'*+I$%&>*'()$"Y+B8()$"+#$%+(0-+6'9)>7+I)-*9
_:&2.1%.2&65.&65.:24&KJ**4& +:#"2$"16&"1%&3J$6"M*.&K:2&1JL.2$+"*&$L7*.L.16"6$:1`&-.&72.3.16&
65.&#"2$"6$:1"*&K:2LJ*"6$:1(&_5.&6:6"*&"+6$:1&+:13$363&:K&652..&6.2L38
[EDE+H-%&3C.3H-%&+B"'*.7)7
@ = ∫ '
A
* √(−2) i ??F\- $ + !
"
E
E ∇
•
$
€
∇
•
$
4
+ λ($
%
$
%
+ ℓ
<
E
) j
PECR
_5.&T$236&6.2L`&P?9?F\-R$`&$3&65.&'$136.$1>]$*M.26&"+6$:1`&.13J2$1;&65"6&65.&65.:24&2.%J+.3&
6:&36"1%"2%&;.1.2"*&2.*"6$#$64&$1&65.&*$L$6&-5.2.&65.&2"%$J3&T$.*%&%.+:J7 * .3(&].2.&$&%.1:6.3&
65.&z$++$&3+"*"2&:K&65.&37"+.6$L.&L.62$+&2
%4
`&"1%&-&$3&n.-6:1U3&;2"#$6"6$:1"*&+:136"16(
_5.&3.+:1%&6.2L`&P!
"
E
9ER&∇
•
$
€
&∇
•
$
4
`&$3&65.&,$1.6$+&6.2L&K:2&65.&2"%$J3&T$.*%(&06&;:#.213&65.&
%41"L$+3& :K& $
%
& :1& 65.& 37"+.6$L.& L"1$K:*%`& -$65& +:J7*$1;& 362.1;65& 3.6& M4& 65.& 3ZJ"2.& :K&
)."2%3*.4U3& K:2+.& +:136"16(& _5.& +:#"2$"16& %.2$#"6$#.3& ∇
•
& .13J2.& ;.1.2"*& +:#"2$"1+.(& _5.&
362J+6J2.&$3&"1"*:;:J3&6:&"&N2:+">647.&"+6$:1&K:2&"&L"33$#.&#.+6:2&T$.*%`&MJ6&-$65&65.&L"33&
2.7*"+.%&M4&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&+J2#"6J2.&3+"*.(
_5.&65$2%&6.2L`&•P$
%
$
%
&c&{
<
E
R`&$3&"&I";2"1;.>LJ*6$7*$.2&6.2L&.1K:2+$1;&65.&+:1362"$16&65"6&$
%
&
$3& 37"+.*$,.& -$65& T$d.%& 1:2L& {
<
(& _5.& LJ*6$7*$.2& •& $3& "& 3+"*"2& T$.*%& %.6.2L$1.%& M4& 65.&
+:1362"$16&.ZJ"6$:1(
[E1E+I)-*9+?P>'()$"7
o"2$"6$:1&:K&65.&"+6$:1&PECR&-$65&2.37.+6&6:&$
4
&4$.*%3&65.&T$.*%&.ZJ"6$:1&K:2&65.&2"%$J3&T$.*%8
!
"
E
&∇
•
∇
•
$
4
&c&E•&$
4
&Y&<
3J77*.L.16.%& M4& 65.& +:1362"$16& $
%
$
%
& Y& t{
<
E
(& o"2$"6$:1& -$65& 2.37.+6& 6:& 2
%4
& 4$.*%3& 65.&
L:%$T$.%&'$136.$1&.ZJ"6$:138
-
%4
&Y&@\-&&P0
%4
L"66.2
&c&0
%4
2"%$J3
R
-5.2.&0
%4
2"%$J3
&$3&65.&.KK.+6$#.&362.33>.1.2;4&6.13:2&%.2$#.%&K2:L&65.&2"%$J3>T$.*%&,$1.6$+&"1%&
+:1362"$16&6.2L3(&e2J+$"**4`&65$3&.KK.+6$#.&362.33>.1.2;4&6.13:2&1..%&1:6&3"6 $3K4&65.&36"1%"2%&
.1.2;4&+:1%$6$:13`&.#.1& 65:J;5&65.&KJ**&#"2$"6$:1"*& 72$1+$7*.&$3&-.**>7:3.%(&_5.& "77"2.16&
.1.2;4>+:1%$6$:1& #$:*"6$:1& $3& 65.& 37"+.6$L.& 72:s.+6$:1& :K& -.**>M.5"#.%& %41"L$+3& $1& 65.&
.d6.1%.%&P37"+.6$L.&c&$1K:2L"6$:1R&L"1$K:*%(
[EKE+J$""-8()$"+($+(0-+!"#$%&'()$"'*+I%'&-X$%M
_5.& $%.16 $T$+"6 $:1&&
$
& ‚&!P$
%
& $
%
R&L" 73&65.&,$1.6$+&6.2L&K:2&$
%
& $1&65.&"+6$:1&PECR&6:&65.&,$1.6$+&
6.2L& K:2& &
$
& $1& 65.& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& L.62$+& P??R(& _5.& +:1362"$16& 6.2L& L"73`& J1%.2& 3L"**&
7.26J2M"6$:13`&6:&65.&5"2L:1$+&7:6.16$"*&:&Y&P?9ER8Pb&
$
R
E
&:K&'Z(&P?ER(&_5.&+:J7*$1;&:K&65.&
35$K6& #.+6:2& 6:& &
?
& 72:+..%3& "1"*:;:J3*48& :1.& "%%3& "& ,$1.6$+& 6.2L& P}
E
9ERP'&
?
9'XR
E
& "1%& "&
5"2L:1$+&7:6.16$"*&$1&&
?
&6:&65.&"+6$:1`&"1%&65.&2.3J*6$1;&'J*.2>I";2"1;.&.ZJ"6$:1&2.+:#.23&
'Z(& P?=R(& _5.& KJ**& #"2$"6$:1"*& K:2LJ*"6$:1& 65J3& J1$T$.3& 65.& 37"+.6$L.& %41"L$+3& P'$136.$1>
]$*M.26R`& 65.& MJMM*.& ;.:L.624& P2"%$J3>T$.*%& ,$1.6$+& 6.2LR`& 65.& 37"+.*$,.& +:1362"$16&
PI";2"1;.& LJ*6$7*$.2R`& "1%& 65.& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& 2.3:1"1+.& P5"2L:1$+& 7:6.16$"*R& $1& "& 3$1;*.&
"+6$:1&72$1+$7*.(
_5$3& K:2LJ*"6$:1& $3& KJ**4& +:#"2$"16`& M"+,;2:J1%>$1%.7.1%.16`& "1%& 3J$6"M*.& K:2& 1JL.2$+"*&
$L7*.L.16"6$:1(& _5.& T$.*%& .ZJ"6$:13& +"1& M.& %$3+2.6$^.%& :1 & "& Cc?& *"66$+.& J3$1;& 36"1%"2%&
6.+51$ZJ.3&K2:L&1JL.2$+"*&2.*"6$ #$64&i?<`&??j`&-$65&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&+::2%$1"6.3&.#:*# .%&
"*:1;3$%.&65.&37"+.6$L.&L.62$+&"6&."+5&6$L.&36.7(
\E+<)78>77)$"+'"9+I>(>%-+<)%-8()$"7
_5.& 72.+.%$1;& 3.+6$:13& 5"#.& .36"M*$35.%& "& +:L7*.6.& ;.:L.62$+& %.2$#"6$:1& :K& 65.& -"27>
MJMM*.& 2.3:1"1+.& "6& [
<
& Y& E\& ]^`& "2$3$1;& K2:L& 65.& J1$T$+"6$:1& :K& )."2%3*.4U3& 7543$+"*&
$1#"2$"163& -$65& 65.& V!0W>O& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& L.62$+(& n:& .d:6$+& L"66.2& $3& 2.ZJ$2.%(& I:+"*&
+"J3"*$64& $3& 72.3.2#.%(& H& KJ**4& +:#"2$"16& #"2$"6$:1"*& K:2LJ*"6$:1& 5"3& M..1& 72.3.16.%(& S.&
1:-&%$3+J33&65.&$L7*$+"6$:13&:K&65.3.&2.3J*63&"1%&:J6*$1.&%$2.+6$:13&K:2&KJ6J2.&2.3."2+5(
\EDE+O>&-%)8'*+U)&>*'()$"
_5.&65.:24&$3&3$LJ*"6$:1>2."%4(&_5.&#"2$"6$:1"*&K:2LJ*"6$:1&:K&a.+(&B&72:#$%.3&"&+:L7*.6.&
3.6& :K& .#:*J6$:1& .ZJ"6$:13& K:2& 65.& 37"+.6$L.& L.62$+& 2
%4
`& 65.& 2"%$J3& T$.*%& $
%
`& "1%& 65.&
$1K:2L"6$:1"*& +::2%$1"6.3& &
$
& "1%& &
?
(& H& M"3$+& 3$LJ*"6$:1& "2+5$6.+6J2.& -:J*%& 72:+..%& "3&
K:**:-3(&_5.&37"6$"*&%:L"$1&$3&%$3+2.6$^.%&:1&"&652..>%$L.13$:1"*&*"66$+.(&_5.&H!W&#"2$"M*.3&
P*"73.`&35$K6`&37"6$"*&L.62$+`&.d62$13$+&+J2#"6J2.R&"2.&.#:*#.%&J3$1;&65.&)aan&K:2LJ*"6$:1&:K&
1JL.2$+"*&2.*"6$#$64(&H6&."+5&6$L.&36.7`&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&+::2%$1"6.3&"2.&J7%"6.%&J3$1;&"&
*."7K2:;&:2&zJ1;.>hJ66" &$16.;2"6:2&"77*$.%&6:&65.&5"2L:1$+&.ZJ"6$:13&P?CR&"1%&P?=R`&-$65&
65.&37"+.6$L.>%.7.1%.16&+:J7*$1;&+:136 "16 3&.#"*J"6.%&K2:L&65.&+J22.16&L.62$+&%"6"(&_5.&
+:1362"$16& .ZJ"6$:1& K:2& $
%
& $3& .1K:2+.%& "6& ." +5& 36.7& J3$1;& "& 72:s.+6$:1& L.65:%(& _5$3&
"2+5$6.+6J2.& $3& %$2.+6*4& $L7*.L.16"M*.& $1& .d$36$1;& 1JL.2$+"*>2.*"6$#$64& +:%.3& 3J+5& "3& 65.&
'$136.$1&_::*,$6(
\E1E+U('C)*)(.+B"'*.7)7
_5.&3L"**>:3+$**"6$:1&"1"*43$3&:K&a.+3(&A&"1%&q&"33JL.3&*$1."2&7.26J2M"6$:13&"M:J6&"&36"M*.&
.ZJ$*$M2$JL(& H& +2J+$"*& :7.1& ZJ.36$:1& $3& -5.65.2& 65.& .ZJ$*$M2$JL& $3& $1%..%& 36"M*.& ";"$136&
1:1*$1."2&7.26J2M"6$:13(&I$1."2&7.26J2M"6$:1&65.:24&"2:J1%&65.&.ZJ$*$M2$JL&#"*J.3&&
$
P<R
&"1%&
&
?
P<R
&72.%$+63&5"2L:1$+&:3+$**"6$:13`&MJ6&1:1*$1."2&6.2L3&$1&65.&7:6.16$"*&"1%&$1&65.&+:J7*$1;&
M.6-..1&37"+.6$L.&"1%&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&3.+6:23&+:J*%&%2$#.&$136"M$*$6$.3&"6&T$1$6.&"L7*$6J%.(&H&
3436.L"6$+& 36"M$*$64& "1"*43$3`& $1+*J%$1;& M:65& *$1."2& .$;.1#"*J.& "1"*43$3& "1%& 1:1*$1."2&
1JL.2$+"*&.#:*J6$:1`&$3&.33.16$"*&M.K:2.&"14&+*"$L3&:K&7543$+"*&2."*$^"M$*$64&+"1&M.&L"%.(
\EKE+?"-%T.+6-P>)%-&-"(7
S5"6& $3& 65.& 6:6"*& .1.2;4& 36:2.%& $1& 65.& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& %.;2..3& :K& K2..%:Lƒ& _5.& 5"2L:1$+&
:3+$**"6$:1&:K&&
$
&"1%&&
?
&+"22$.3&.1.2;4&72:7:26$:1"*&6:&[
<
E
&6$L.3&65.&"L7*$6J%.&3ZJ"2.%(&r:2&
3L"**&:3+$**"6$:13`&65$3&.1.2;4&$3&M:J1%.%&"1%&+:162:**"M*.(&H&+:L7"2$3:1&-$65&65.&.d:6$+>
L"66.2& .1.2;4& .36$L"6.3& :K& 65.& :2$;$1"*& H*+JM$.22.& L.62$+& i?j& "1%& $63& 2.T$1.L.163& iE`& qj&
-:J*%&+*"2$K4&-5.65.2&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&K2"L.-:2,&:KK.23&"&;.1J$1.&.1.2;.6$+&"%#"16";.&:2&
L.2.*4&2.%$362$MJ6.3&65.&.1.2;4&MJ%;.6&M.6-..1&37"+.6$L.&"1%&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&3.+6:23(
\ENE+QC7-%='()$"'*+U)T"'(>%-7
_5.&E\>]^&2.3:1"1+.&72.%$+63&"&+5"2"+6.2$36$+&3$;1"6J2.8&"14&7543$+"*&72:+.33&+:J7*.%&6:&
65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&L.62$+& -:J*%& .d5$M$6& :3+$**"6$:13& "6& 1& Y& ?& ]^(&01&65.&;2"#$6"6$:1"*>-"#.&
3.+6:2`&65$3&+:J*%&L"1$K.36&"3&"&ZJ"3$>L:1:+52:L"6$+&;2"#$6"6$:1"*>-"#.&3$;1"*&"6&?&]^(&_5$3&
K2.ZJ.1+4&*$.3&-$65$1&65.&3.13$6$#$64&M"1%&:K&7*"11.%&37"+.>M"3.%&%.6.+6:23&3J+5&"3&I0aH&
"1%&72:7:3.%&;2:J1%>M"3.%&%.6.+6:23&3J+5&"3&65.&'$136.$1&_.*.3+:7.(&S5$*.&65.&"L7*$6J%.&
:K&3J+5&"& 3$;1"*& %.7.1%3&:1&65.& J1,1:-1&+:J7*$1;&362.1;65&{`&.#.1&"1& J77.2&*$L$6&K2:L&
;2"#$6"6$:1"*>-"#.&:M3.2#"6$:13&-:J*%&7*"+.&L."1$1;KJ*&+:1362"$163&:1&65.&65.:24(
\ESE+]>'"(>&+J$%%-8()$"7
_5.& M2$%;.& ZJ"16$64& {& v& 9
.KK
& Y& #9+PA\
E
R& Y& 9P+E\R& $1#:*#.3& N*"1+,U3& 2.%J+.%& +:136 "16&
.d7*$+$6*4`&$1%$+"6$1;&65"6&ZJ"16JL&.KK.+63&"2.&$162$13$+&6:&65.&-"27>MJMM*.&%41"L$+3&"6&65.&
*.#.*&:K&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&L.62$+(&H&KJ**&ZJ"16JL&62."6L.16GZJ"16$^$1;&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&
+::2%$1"6.3& &
$
& "1%& &
?
& "1%& +:L7J6$1;& 65.& 2.3J*6$1;& ZJ"16JL& +:22.+6$:13& 6:& 65.& MJMM*.&
%41"L$+3G$3&"&1"6J2"*&1.d6&36.7(&_5.&5"2L:1$+&362J+6J2.&:K&65.&3L"**>:3+$**"6$:1&.ZJ"6$:13&
3J;;.363& 65"6& 65.& ZJ"16JL& 65.:24& L"4& M.& .d"+6*4& 3:*#"M*.& "6& *."%$1;& :2%.2`& -$65& 65.&
$1K:2L"6$:1"*&ZJ"16"&7*"4$1;&65.&2:*.&:K&k$1K:2L"6$:1"*&75:1:13l&:K&65.&-"27&MJMM*.(
^E+J$"8*>7)$"
S.&5"#.&72.3.16.%&"&J1$T$.%&65.:2.6$+"*&K2"L.-:2,& 65"6&%.2$#.3&-"27>%2$#.&%41"L$+3&K2:L&
$1K:2L"6$:1"*&;.:L.624`&.*$L$1"6$1;&65.&.d:6$+>L"66.2&2.ZJ$2.L.16&65"6&5"3&*:1;&M..1&65.&
72$1+$7"*& :M36"+*.& 6:& 65.& 7543$+"*& 2."*$^"M$*$64& :K& -"27>%2$#.& 37"+.6$L.3(& _5.& K2"L.-:2,&
2.363&:1& 65.& +:1#.2;.1+.& :K& 6-:& $1%.7.1%.16& *$1.3& :K& -:2,`& "1%& $63& L"$1& 2.3J*63& +"1& M.&
3JLL"2$^.%&"3&652..&$16.2*:+,$1;&"+5$.#.L.163(
r$236`&)."2%3*.4U3&$1#"2$"163G65.&6.L7:2"*&+:136"16&X
<
&Y&?&3`&65.&K:2+.&+:136"16&!
"
&Y	+X
<
E
`&
"1%&65.&37"+.*$,.&2"%$J3&T$.*%&$
%
G%.T$1.&65.&7543$+"*&M"+,M:1.&:K&"&-"27>MJMM*.&2.3:1"1+.&
"6&"1;J*"2&K2.ZJ.1+4&[
<
&Y&E\&]^(&_5.&%$L.13$:1*.33&$%.16$64&PCR`&+:11.+6$1;&65.&2"6$:&:K&!
"
&
6:&65.&N*"1+,&K:2+.&-$65&65.&2"6$:&:K&X
<
& 6:&65.&N*"1+,&6$L.&652:J;5&.d"+6* 4&E\`&2.#."*3&"&%..7&
362J+6J2"*&2.3:1"1+.&M2$%;$1;&L"+2:3+:7$+& "1%&N*"1+,>3+"*.&7543$+3(&_5.&1"6J2"*&K2.ZJ.1+4&
[
<
&.L.2;.3&"3&65.&J1$ZJ.&#"*J.&+:13$36.16&-$65&65$3&M2$%;.(
a.+:1%`& 65.& V!0W>O& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& L.62$+& 72:#$%.3& 65.& ;.:L.62$+& %.2$#"6$:1& :K& 65$3&
2.3:1"1+.(&)4&72:L:6$1;&65.&2"%$J3&T$.*%&6:&"1&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&+::2%$1"6.&&
$
&"1%&.d6.1%$1;&
65.&72:7.2>6$L.&$16.2#"*&6:&$1+*J%.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&+:L7:1.163`&-.&5"#.&35:-1&65"6&3L"**&
:3+$**"6$:13& :K& 65.& MJMM*.& 2"%$J3& 3"6$3K4& 'Z(& P?CRG"& 3$L7*.& 5"2L:1$+& .ZJ"6$:1& "6& 65.&
)."2%3*.4&K2.ZJ.1+4(&_5.&2.3:1"1+.&$3&1:6&.d6.21"**4&$L7:3.%m&$6&$3&"&+J2#"6J2.&.$;.1L:%.&
:K& 65.& .d6.1%.%& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& L.62$+`& "2$3$1;& K2:L& 65.& 3.+6$:1"* & +J2#"6J2.& $1& 65.& &
$
&
%$2.+6$:1(&_5.&3"L.&+:1362J+6$:1&"77*$.3&6:&65.&35$K6&#.+6:2&652:J;5&65.&MJMM*.&+::2%$1"6.&
&
?
`& 4$.*%$1;& "& J1$#.23"*&:3+$**"6$:1& K2.ZJ.1+4& K:2& "**& %41"L$+"*& %.;2..3& :K& K2..%:L& :K& 65.&
-"27&MJMM*.(
_5$2%`& 65.& .d6.1%.%& +:1T$;J2"6$:1& 37"+.& P*
%
`& &
+
R& "**:-3& -"27>MJMM*.& %41"L$+3& 6:& K:**:-&
;.:%.3$+3& -$65:J6& .d:6$+& L"66.2& -5$*.& 72.3.2#$1;& *:+"*& +"J3"*$64(& _5.& "77"2.16& .1.2;4>
+:1%$6$:1& #$:*"6$:1`& 3..1& K2:L& 65.& 37"+.6$L.& 3JML"1$K:*%`& $3& "& 72:s.+6$:1& "26$K"+6G65.&
35"%:-&:K&"&-.**>M.5"#.%&;.:%.3$+&$1&65.&KJ**&L"1$K:*%(&n:&+*:3.%&6$L.*$,.&+J2#.3&"2$3.`&"1%&
1:&:M3.2#.2&L."3J2.3&"&*:+"*&#.*:+$64&.d+..%$1;&,(
_:;.65.2`&65.3.&652..&2.3J*63&+:136$6J6.&"&+:L7*.6.`&+:#"2$"16`& 3$LJ*"6$:1>2."%4&65.:24&:K&
-"27>%2$#.&%41"L$+3&2::6.%&$1&$1K:2L"6$:1&;.:L.624(&_5.&#"2$"6$:1"*&K:2LJ*"6$:1&:K&a.+(&B&
72:#$%.3& 65.& "+6$:1& 72$1+$7*.& K2:L& -5$+5& "**& T$.*%& .ZJ"6$:13& K:**:-`& "1%& 65.& 1JL.2$+"*&
"2+5$6.+6J2.& :J6*$1.%& $1& a.+(& @& :KK.23& "& +:1+2.6.& 7"65& 6:-"2%& +:L7J6"6$:1"*& .d7*:2"6$:1(&
S5$*.& 3$;1$T$+"16& :7.1& ZJ.36$:13& 2. L"$1G36"M$*$64`& .1.2;4& MJ%;.6 `& :M3.2#"6$:1"*&
+:1362"$163`&ZJ"16JL& +:22.+6$:13G65.& K2"L.-:2,& 72.3.16.%&5.2.& %.L:1362"6.3& 65"6& 65.&
J1$T$+"6$:1&:K&7543$+"*&$1#"2$"163&-$65&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&;.:L.624&:7.13&"&1.-&"1%&7:6.16$"**4&
62"13K:2L"6$#.&"772:"+5&6:&65.&7543$+3&:K&K"36.2>65"1>*$;56&62"#.*&-$65$1&65.&M:J1%"2$.3&:K&
;.1.2"*&2.*"6$#$64(
B8M"$X*-9T&-"(7
_5.&72.7"2"6$:1&:K& 65$3&L"1J3+2$76&M.1.T$6.%&K2:L&65.&"33$36"1+.&:K&"%#"1+.%&*"1;J";.>L:%.*&6::*3&
65"6&3J77:26.%&#"2$:J3&36";.3&:K&65.&-2$6$1;&"1%&.%$6:2$"*&72:+.33(&01&7"26$+J*"2`&+:1#.23"6$:1"*&H0&
3436.L3&-.2.&J3.%&6:&5.*7&2.T$1.&65.&362J+6J2.&:K&65.&6.d6`&$L72:#.&+*"2$64&:K&.d72.33$:1`&"1%&"33$36&
$1&:2;"1$^$1;& M$M*$:;2"75$+&"1%&+:1+.76J"*&L"6.2$"*(&_5.3.&6::*3&-.2.&.L7*:4.%&"3& "$%3&$1&%2"K6$1;`&
.%$6$1;`& "1%& 364*$36$+& 2.#$3$:1(& H**& 75$*:3:75$+"*& $16.272.6"6$:13`& +:1+.76J"*& "2;JL.163`& "1%& T$1"*&
.%$6:2$"*&%.+$3$:13&2.L"$1&65.&2.37:13$M$*$64&:K&65.&"J65:23(
6-#-%-"8-7
i?j&W(&H*+JM$.22.`&k_5.&S"27&!2$#.8&]47.2>r"36&_2"#.*&S$65$1&„.1.2"*&z.*"6$#$64`l&AB+;;),+BC+"'CD6+".69C
-7+<).=&DD`&IBC&P?==AR(
iEj&e(&o"1&!.1&)2:.+,`&kH&…S"27&!2$#.U&-$65&W:2.&z."3:1"M*.&_:6"*&'1.2;4&z.ZJ$2.L.163`l&AB+;;),+BC+"'C
D6+".69C-7+<).=&DW`&C=BC&P?===R(
iCj&f(&n"6"p 2$:`&kS"27&!2$#.&-$65&†.2:&'d7"13$:1`l&AB+;;),+BC+"'CD6+".69C-7+<).=&D^`&??qB&PE<<ER(
iAj&H(&):M2$+,&"1%&„(&W"26$2.`&k0162:%J+$1;&N543$+"*&S"27&!2$#.3`l&AB+;;),+BC+"'CD6+".69C-7+<).=&K\`&
?<q<<=&PE<E?R(
iqj&'(&S(&I.16^`&k)2.",$1;&65.&S"27&)"22$.28&]47.2>r"36&a:*$6:13&$1&'$136.$1&„2"#$64`l&AB+;;),+BC+"'C
D6+".69C-7+<).=&K\`&<Bq<?q&PE<E?R(
iFj&)."2%3*.4`&0"1&PH72$*&EC`&E<EFR&E+8)"2CF+7GC 57)<HCF).#I6.CJ*I.),CE+..H7;(&56673899%:$(:2;9?<(qE@?9
^.1:%:(?=B?C?=@(&
iBj&!(&'(& )*"+,-.**`&k_5.&VM3.2#.2>!.7.1%.16&01K:2L"6$:1&W.62$+&PV!0W>OR`l&†.1:%:`&!V08&?<(qE@?9
^.1:%:(?=<EqB?C&PE<EFR(
i@j&!(&'(& )*"+,-.**`&k_5.&)*"+,-.**&01K:2L"6$:1>W.62$+&O1$T$+"6$:1&PV!0W>O&#?(ER`l&72.72$16&PE<EFR(
i=j&!(&'(& )*"+,-.**`&k_5.&]$**M$**4&_V'&r:J1%24 ` l&†.1:%:`&!V08&?<(qE@?9^.1:%:(?=??B??<&PE<EFR(
i?<j&z(&H21:-$66`&a(&!.3.2`&"1%&e(&S(&W$31.2`&k!41"L$+"*&a62J+6J2.&"1%&!.T$1$6$:1&:K&'1.2;4&$1&„.1.2"*&
z.*"6$#$64`l&/#=;),+BC$H<)HK&DDW`&?CEE&P?=q=R(
i??j&e(&S(&W$31.2`&h(&a(&_5:21.`&"1%&f(&H(&S5..*.2` &-7+<).+.)I"&PS(&](&r2..L"1`&?=BCR(
B;;-"9)@+BE+?##-8()=-+U(%-773?"-%T.+H-"7$%+#%$&+<)&-"7)$"'*+L%$_-8()$"
BEDE+U-(>;Y+H0-+?@(-"9-9+A-(%)8
S.&+:13$%.2&65.&KJ**&PA&c&"R>%$L.13$:1"*&L"1$K:*%&E
.d6
&Y&E
A
&v&E
$1K:
`&-5.2.&E
A
&$3&65.&K:J2>
%$L.13$:1"*& 37"+.6$L.& "1%& E
$1K:
& $3& 65.& ">%$L.13$:1"*& $1K:2L"6$:1& L"1$K:*%& -$65&
+::2%$1"6.3&&
+
&P+&Y&?`&‡`&"R(&r:2&65.&-"27>MJMM*.&72:M*.L`&"&Y&E`&-$65&&
?
&Y&&
$
&P2"%$J3&T$.*%R&
"1%&&
E
&Y&&
?
&PMJMM*.&#.*:+$64R(&_5.&KJ**&L.62$+&6",.3&65.&M*:+,>%$";:1"*&K:2L8
-5.2.&2
%4
&$3&65.&37"+.6$L.&L.62$+&P$1+*J%$1;&65.&-"27>MJMM*.&;.:L.624R&"1%&ˆ
+3
&Y&%$";P{
E
`&
}
E
R&$3&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&L.62$+(&S.&.L75"3$^.&65"6&65.&M*:+,>%$";:1"*&"13"6^&$3&65.&*."%$1;>
:2%.2&362J+6J2.m&+2:33>6.2L3&2
%+
&+:J7*$1;&37"+.6$L.&"1%&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&+::2%$1"6.3&"2$3.&"6&
1.d6&:2%.2&"1%&+:162$MJ6.&6:&65.&.KK.+6$#.&362.33>.1.2;4(
';
E
.d6
= 2
%4
(*) '*
%
'*
4
+ γ
+3
(&) '&
+
'&
3
PH(?R
BE1E+?)"7(-)"+?P>'()$"7+)"+(0-+?@(-"9-9+U;'8-
_5.& '$136.$1&6.13:2& :K& 65.& KJ**& L.62$+& %.+:L7:3.3& #$"&65.&„"J33>e:%"^^$&2.*"6$:13(& r:2& "&
72:%J+6& L.62$+& -$65& 3L"**& +2:33>6.2L3`& 65.& P•€R& +:L7:1.163& :K& 65.& .d6.1%.%& '$136.$1&
.ZJ"6$:13&"2.8
-5.2.&-
PA!R
•€
&$3&65.&36"1%"2%&K:J2>%$L.13$:1"*&'$136.$1&6.13:2`&$
P$1K:R
+3
&$3&65.&z$++$&6.13:2&:K&
65.& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& L.62$+`& "1%& L
%4
& +:**.+63& 65.& .d62$13$+& +J2#"6J2.& +:162$MJ6$:13& K2:L& 65.&
.LM.%%$1;&:K&E
A
&$1&E
.d6
(&_5.&KJ**&.d6.1%.%&'$136.$1&.ZJ"6$:13&$1&#"+JJL&"2.8
N2:s.+6$1;&:16:&65.&37"+.6$L.&3.+6:28
H& K:J2>%$L.13$:1"*& :M3.2#.2& $16.272.63& 65.& 2$;56>5"1%& 3$%.& "3& "1& .KK.+6$#.& 362.33>.1.2;4&
6.13:28
BEKE+!"#$%&'()$"'*+J$"(%)C>()$"7+($+(0-+?"-%T.+<-"7)(.
_5.&.KK.+6$#.&.1.2;4&%.13$64&3..1&M4&"&K:J2>%$L.13$:1"*&:M3.2#.2&-$65&K:J2>#.*:+$64&6
%
&$38
-
P.d6R
•€
= -
PA!R
•€
− ?E 2
%4
γ
+3
$
P$1K:R
+3
+ L
%4
PH(ER
-
P.d6R
M?
= 0
PH(CR
-
PA!R
•€
= ?E 2
%4
γ
+3
$
P$1K:R
+3
− L
%4
PH(AR
@\-&0
P.KKR
•€
,
A
= ?E 2
%4
γ
+3
$
P$1K:R
+3
− L
%4
PH(qR
ρ
.KK
,
E
= 0
P.KKR
•€
6
%
6
4
PH(FR
r:2& 65.& :3+$**"6$1;& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& +::2%$1"6.3& &
$
& Y& &
P<R
z
& c& b&
$
& 3$1P[
<
XR& "1%& &
?
& Y& &
P<R
)
& c& b&
?
&
3$1P[
<
XR`&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&z$++$&3+"*"2&.# "*J"6.3&6:8
_5.&6$L.>"#.2";.%&.KK.+6$#.&.1.2;4&%.13$64&$38
_5$3&$3&1.;"6$#.&G&72.+$3.*4&65.&3$;1"6J 2.&:K&.d:6$+&L"66.2&$1&65.&36"1%"2%&K:J2>%$L.13$:1"*&
"1"*43$3(
BENE+:?J+'"9+O?J+B"'*.7)7
_5.&-.",&.1.2;4&+:1%$6$:1&PS'eR&2.ZJ$2.3&0
%4
&6
%
&6
4
&‰&<&K:2&"**&6$L.*$,.&6
%
(&_5.&1J**&.1.2;4&
+:1%$6$:1&Pn'eR&2.ZJ$2.3&0
%4
&8
%
&8
4
&‰&<&K:2&"**&1J**&8
%
(&r2:L&.ZJ"6$:1&PH(@R8
):65& S'e& "1%& n'e& "2.&#$:*"6.%& M4&65.& .KK.+6$#.& 362.33>.1.2;4& 6.13:2(& _5$3& $3& .d"+6*4&65.&
#$:*"6$:1&65"6&65.&36"1%"2%&H*+JM$.22.&"1"*43$3&$%.16$T$.3&"3&2.ZJ$2$1;&.d:6$+&L"66.2(
]:-.#.2`&$1&65.&KJ**&.d6.1%.%&37"+.`&65.&6:6"*&.1.2;4>L:L.16JL&$38
-5.2.& N
M
& Y& P6
%
`& <
+
R& $3& "& 6$L.*$,.& #.+6:2& $1& 65.& .d6.1%.%& 37"+.& "1%& <
+
& Y& '&
+
9'X& "2.& 65.&
$1K:2L"6$:1"*&#.*:+$6$.3(&_5.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&+:162$MJ6$:1&$38
$
P$1K:R
= γ
+3
$
P$1K:R
+3
= −[
<
E
,
E
(ℓ
E
(δ&
$
)
E
+ Λ
E
(δ&
?
)
E
) cos(2ω
<
τ) + ···
PH(BR
⟨ρ
.KK
⟩ ,
E
= −,
A
?F\- [
<
E
,
E
[ℓ
E
⟨(δ&
$
)
E
⟩ + Λ
E
⟨(δ&
?
)
E
⟩]
PH(@R
0
P.KKR
•€
6
%
6
4
= ⟨ρ
.KK
⟩ ,
E
< 0
PH(=R
0
P.d6R
M?
N
M
N
?
= 0
PA!R
•€
6
%
6
4
+ 0
P$1K:R
+3
<
+
<
3
PH(?<R
_5$3&$3&L"1$K.36*4&1:1>1.;"6$#.&G&$6&$3&65.&,$1.6$+&.1.2;4&:K&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&:3+$**"6$:13(&
_5.&6:6"*&.1.2;4&$1&65.&.d6.1%.%&37"+.&3"6$3T$.38
_5.&S'e&$3&3"6$3T$.%&$1&65.&KJ**&65.:24(&_5.&K:J2>%$L.13$:1"*&#$:*"6$:1&$3&.16$2.*4&"1&"26$K"+6&
:K&72:s.+6$1;&:J6& 65.& $1K:2L"6$:1"*&%.;2..3& :K&K2..%:L(& _5.& 1.;"6$#.&.1.2;4& 65"6& "&K:J2>
%$L.13$:1"*& :M3.2#.2& "662$MJ6.3& 6:& .d:6$+& L"66.2& $3`& $1& 65.& KJ**& 65.:24`& 3$L7*4& 65.& %.T$+$6&
+2."6.%&M4&$;1:2$1;&65.&7:3$6$#.&,$1.6$+&.1.2;4&36:2.%&$1&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&:3+$**"6$:13(
BESE+J$&;'%)7$"+X)(0+`'*>5'3`*-)"
_5$3&L.+5"1$3L&$3&362J+6J2"**4&$%.16$+"*&6:&65.&h"*J^">h *.$1&2.%J+6$:1&:K&T$#.>%$L.13$:1"*&
#"+JJL& ;2"#$64(& 01& 65"6& +"3.`& 65.& T$#.>%$L.13$:1"*& #"+JJL& '$136.$1& .ZJ"6$:13& -
Pq!R
M?
& Y& <&
72:s.+6&:16:&K:J2>%$L.13$:1"*&'$136.$1>W"d-.**&.ZJ"6$:138
_5.&.*.+62:L";1.6$+&362.33>.1.2;4&6.13:2&0
P'WR
•€
&5"3&$1%.T$1$6.&3$;1&G&$6&#$:*"6.3&65.&362:1;&
.1.2;4&+:1%$6$:1&K:2&+.26"$1&T$.*%&+:1T$;J2"6$:13&G&4.6&1:&k.d:6$+&.*.+62:L";1.6$+&L"66.2l&
$3& $162:%J+.%(& _5.& 362.33>.1.2;4& $3& 3$L7*4& 65.& 35"%:-& :K& T$#.>%$L.13$:1"*& #"+JJL&
;.:L.624(
01&:J2&+:1362J+6$:1`&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&%$L.13$:13&7*"4&65.&2:*.&:K&65.&h"*J^">h*.$1&+$2+*.`&
"1%&65.&.KK.+6$#.&-"27>MJMM*.&362.33>.1.2;4&7*"43&65.& 2:*.& :K& 65.&.*.+62:L";1.6$+&362.33>
.1.2;4(&_5.&"1"*:;4& $3&1:6&L.2.*4&5.J2$36$+8&M:65&"2.&$136"1+.3&:K&65.&;.1.2"*&„"J33>e:%"^^$&
72:s.+6$:1& 65.:2.L& K:2& 72:%J+6& L"1$K:*%3(& _5.& :1*4& %$KK.2.1+.& $3& 65"6& :J2& $1K:2L"6$:1"*&
0
P$1K:R
+3
<
+
<
3
= ?E[ℓ
E
ω
<
E
(δ&
$
)
E
+ Λ
E
ω
<
E
(δ&
?
)
E
] ≥ 0
PH(??R
0
P.d6R
M?
N
M
N
?
= 0
PA!R
•€
6
%
6
4
+ 0
P$1K:R
+3
<
+
<
3
≥ 0
PH(?ER
-
PA!R
•€
= @\-&0
P'WR
•€
,
A
PH(?CR
%$L.13$:13&"2.&:M3.2#.2>%.7.1%.16&"1%&+"224&7543$+"*&$16.272.6"6$:1&652:J;5&65.&V!0W>O&
K2"L.-:2,`&-5.2."3&65.&h"*J^">h*.$1&+$2+*.&$3&"&T$d.%&;.:L.62$+&362J+6J2.(
B;;-"9)@+FE+a)"-'%)5-9+O>&-%)8'*+U)&>*'()$"
FEDE+U-(>;
_:&#.2$K4&65.&"1"*46$+"*&72.%$+6$:13&"1%&%.L:1362"6.&36"M$*$64`&-.&72.3.16&"&*$1."2$^.%&?c?!&
3$LJ*"6$:1&:K&65.&-"27>MJMM*.&2.3:1"1+.(&S.&+:13$%.2&"&3$1;*.&37"6$"*&%$L.13$:1&*&-$65&"&
MJMM*.&:K&2"%$J3&7
3
&+.16.2.%&"6&*&Y&<`&"1%&.#:*#.&65.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&+::2%$1"6.3&&
$
P.R&"1%&&
?
P.R&
"3&KJ1+6$:13&:K&6$L.(
_5.&*$1."2$^.%&.ZJ"6$:13&:K&L:6$:1`&%.2$#.%&K2:L&65.&"+6$:1&$1&a.+6$:1&B`&"2.8
-$65&[
<
&Y&E\&]^(&_5.3.&"2.&$1%.7.1%.16&5"2L:1$+&:3+$**"6:23&"6&65.&3"L.&K2.ZJ.1+4&G&65.&
%.;.1.2"+4&2.T*.+63&65.&J1$#.23"*&+5"2"+6.2&:K&65.&2.3:1"1+.(
$L7:26&1JL74&"3&17&$L7:26&L"67*:6*$M(747*:6&"3&7*6
333+L'%'&-(-%7+#%$&+(0-+;';-%+333
6"J<& Y& ?(<& Š& 3& P)."2%3*.4‹3& 6.L7:2"*& $1#"2$"16R& :L.;"<& Y& E(<& Œ& 17(7$& Š& 2"%93`& 1"6J2"*&
K2.ZJ.1+4& %.*6"0<& Y& ?(<& Š& $1$6$"*& "L7*$6J%.& :K& b0•z& P"2M$62"24& J1$63R& %.*6"0<•%:6& Y& <(<& Š&
$1$6$"*&#.*:+$64
'
E
Pb&
$
R'.
E
+ ω
<
E
δ&
$
= 0
P)(?R
'
E
Pb&
?
R'.
E
+ ω
<
E
δ&
?
= 0
P)(ER
?##-8()=-+ -"-%T.39-"7)(.+ 78'*)"T+
b)**>7(%'()=-c
25:•3+"*.&Y&?(<
333+H)&-+T%)9+b7-=-%'*+;-%)$97c+333
_&Y&6"J<&Š&7.2$:%&Y&?&3&1•7.2$:%3&Y&q&6&Y&17(*$137"+.P<(<`&1•7.2$:%3&Œ&_`&E<<<R
333+B"'*.()8+7$*>()$"+#$%+*)"-'%+$78)**'($%+333
d!e6b(c+f+B+8$7bgh+(c+i+b=hjghc+7)"bgh+(c
%.*6"0&Y&%.*6"0<&Œ&17(+:3P:L.;"<&Œ&6R&c&P%.*6"0<•%:6&9&:L.;"<R&Œ&17(3$1P:L.;"<&Œ&6R
?##-8()=-+-"-%T.+9-"7)(.+b>;+($+'+8$"7('"(+
#'8($%c
25:•.KK&Y&25:•3+"*.&Œ&%.*6"0ŒŒE
333+L*$(+d!e6b(c+333
7*6(T$;J2.PT$;3$^.YP@`&ARR&7*6(7*:6P6`&%.*6"0`&*"M.*Y2‹Ž•%.*6"&0•zP6RŽ‹R&7*6("d5*$1.P<(<`&+:*:2Y‹, ‹`&
*$1.-$%65Y<(qR& 7*6(d*"M.*P2‹Ž•6"JŽ& P3R‹R& 7*6 (4*"M.*P2‹Ž•%.*6"& 0•zŽ& P"2M(& J1$63R‹R&
7*6(6$6*.P2‹I$1."2$^.%&01K:2L"6$:1"*&W:%.8& Ž•%%:6 ••%.* 6 "&0•z‘&c&•:L.;"•<’E&•%.*6"&0•z&Y&<Ž`&
Ž•:L.;"•<& Y& E•7$Ž& 2"%93‹R& 7*6(;2$%P_2J.`& "*75"Y<(CR& 7*6(*.;.1%PR& 7*6 (6$;56•*"4:J6PR&
7*6(3"#.T$;P“%.*6"0z•6$L.•3.2$.3(71;“`&%7$YC<<R
333+L*$(+ke-##b(c+333
7*6(T$;J2.PT$;3$^.YP@`& ARR& 7*6(7*:6P6`& 25:•.KK`& +:*:2Y‹+2$L3:1‹`& *"M.*Y2‹Ž•25:•••L"652L•.KK‘‘
P6R& •72:76:& P•%.* 6 "& 0•zR’EŽ‹R& 7*6("d5*$1.P<(<`& +:*:2Y‹,‹`& *$1.-$%65Y<(qR& 7*6(d*"M.*P2‹Ž•6"JŽ&
P3R‹R& 7*6(4*"M.*P2‹Ž•25:•••L"652L•.KK‘‘Ž& P"2M(& J1$63R‹R& 7*6(6$6*.P2‹'KK.+6$#.& '1.2;4>!.13$64&
N2:d4& K2:L& 01K:2L"6$:1"*& W:%.‹R& 7*6 (;2$%P_2J.`& "*75"Y<(CR& 7*6(*.;.1%PR& 7*6(6$;56•*"4:J6PR&
7*6(3"#.T$;P“25:•.KK•6$L.•3.2$.3(71;“`&%7$YC<<R
7*6(35:-PR
FE1E+!")()'*+J$"9)()$"7+'"9+L'%'&-(-%7
S.& +5::3.&$1$6$"*& +:1%$6$:13& +:22.37:1%$1;& 6:& "& 3L"**&7.26J2M"6$:1&:K& 65.& MJMM*.& 2"%$J3&
-$65&^.2:&$1$6$"*&#.*:+$648
_5.&+:J7*$1;&7"2"L.6.23&"2.&3.6&M4&65.&3.*K>+:13$36.1+4&+:1%$6$:13&:K&a.+6$:1&A8
{&Y&,9PE\&7
3
R&-$65&7
3
&Y&?&L`&;$#$1;&{&u&NE[[+l+Dh
[
+&(&_5.1&9
.KK
&Y	P+A\
E
&{R&u&DED[+l+Dh
mSD
+
MT(&r:2&65.&MJMM*.&+::2%$1"6.`&}&Y&,9PE\&<
;
R&-$65&<
;
&Y&<(?,`&;$#$1;&}&u&NE[[+l+Dh
\
+&(
FEKE+6-7>*(7
_5.&"1"*46$+"*&3:*J6$:13&"2.8
):65& :3+$**"6.& "6& .d"+6*4& 1
<
& Y& ?& ]^& P7.2$:%& 0& Y& ?& 3& Y& X
<
R`& +:1T$2L$1;& 65.& 72.%$+6.%&
.$;.1K2.ZJ.1+4(& _5.& :3+$* * " 6$:13& "2.& 36"M*.& G& 1:& ;2:-65& :2& %.+"4& G& "3& .d7.+6.%& K:2& "&
+:13.2#"6$#.&3436.L&%.2$#.%&K2:L&"&#"2$"6$:1"*&72$1+$7*.(
_5.&.KK.+6$#.&.1.2;4&%.13$64`&+:L7J6.%&K2:L&H77.1%$d&H`&.ZJ"6$:1&PH(@R`&:3+$**"6.3&"38
δ&
$
(0) = M
$
= 0.01, 'Pb&
$
R'.g
.Y<
= 0
P)(C"R
δ&
?
(0) = 0, 'Pb&
?
R'.g
.Y<
= M
?
ω
<
= 0.005 × 2π
P)(CMR
δ&
$
(.) = M
$
cos(ω
<
.) = 0.01 cos(2π.)
P)(AR
δ&
?
(.) = M
?
sin(ω
<
.) = 0.005 sin(2π.)
P)(qR
_5.&6$L.>"#.2";.%&L";1$6J%.&$38
aJM36$6J6$1;& 65.& 1JL.2$+"*& #"*J.3`& 65$3& .#"*J"6.3& 6:& "772:d$L"6.*4& DE1+ l+ Dh
1\
+ MTj&n& G&
*"2;.`&MJ6&L"14&:2%.23&:K&L";1$6J%.&*.33&65"1&65.&N*"1+,&%.13$64&PSEDW+l+Dh
^W
+MTj&nR& "1%&
+:L7"2"M*.& 6:& 1J+*."2& %.13$64& P1EK+ l+ Dh
D[
+ MTj&nR& 3+" * .%& M4& 65.& 3ZJ"2.& :K& 65.& I:2.16^&
K"+6:2& K:2& 65.& .KK.+6$#.& MJMM*.& #.*:+$64(& e2J+$"**4` & 65$3& .1.2;4& $3& 1:6& .d:6$+& G& $6& $3& 65.&
72:s.+6.%&35"%:-&:K&:2%$1"24&7:3$6$#.>%.T$1$6.&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&,$1.6$+&.1.2;4(
FENE+U('C)*)(.+R"9-%+O$"*)"-'%+L-%(>%C'()$"7
S.& M2$.T*4& "%%2.33& 65.& ZJ.36$:1& :K& 1:1*$1."2& 36"M$*$64(& 01+*J%$1;& 65.& *."%$1;& 1:1*$1."2&
+:22.+6$:1&6:&65.&2.36:2$1;&7:6.16$"*8
65.&.ZJ"6$:1&:K&L:6$:1&M.+:L.38
_5$3&$3&65.&!JKT$1;&.ZJ"6$:1(&r:2&•
nI
&”&<&P36$KK.1$1;&1:1*$1."2$64R`&65.&:3+$**"6$:1&K2.ZJ.1+4&
35$K63&J7-"2%&-$65&"L7*$6J%.&MJ6&65.&L:6$:1&2.L"$13&M:J1%.%(&r:2&•
nI
&~&<&P3:K6.1$1;R`&65.&
L:6$:1&2.L"$13&M:J1%.%&72:#$%.%&65.&"L7*$6J%.&3"6$3T$.3&gb&
$
g&~&P[
<
E
9g•
nI
gR
?9E
(&_5.&3$;1& :K&
•
nI
& $3& %.6.2L$1.%& M4& 65.& +J2#"6J2.& :K& 65.& $1K:2L"6$:1"*& L.62$+& "6& 5$;5.2& :2%.2m& "& KJ**&
%.6.2L$1"6$:1& 2.ZJ$2.3& 65.& 1:1*$1."2& +:L7*.6$:1& :K& 65.& V!0W>O& K2"L.-:2,`& -5$+5& -.&
ρ
.KK
(.) = −,
A
?F\- [
<
E
,
E
[ℓ
E
M
$
E
cos
E
(2π.) + Λ
E
M
?
E
sin
E
(2π.)]
P)(FR
|⟨ρ
.KK
⟩| = ,
E
CE\- ω
<
E
[ℓ
E
M
$
E
+ Λ
E
M
?
E
]
P)(BR
:(δ&
$
) = ?E 8 (δ&
$
)
E
+ ?A λ
nI
(δ&
$
)
A
P)(@R
'
E
Pb&
$
R'.
E
+ ω
<
E
δ&
$
+ λ
nI
(δ&
$
)
C
= 0
P)(=R
%.K.2&6:&KJ6J2.&-:2,(&]:-.#.2`&K:2&65.&3L"**&7.26J2M"6$:13&+:13$%.2.%&5.2.&PM
$
&Y&<(<?R`&65.&
1:1*$1."2&+:22.+6$:13&"2.&:K&:2%.2&M
$
E
&‚&?<
tA
&2.*"6$#.&6:&65.&*$1."2&6.2L`&"1%&65.&*$1."2$^.%&
"1"*43$3&$3&"1&.d+.**.16&"772:d$L"6$:1(
FESE+<-(-%&)")"T+o+#%$&+U-*#3J$"7)7(-"8.
_5.& 3.+:1%& +:J7*$1;& 3+"*.& }`& $162:%J+.%& $1& a.+6$:1& q`& +"1& M.&T$d.%& M4& 2.ZJ$2$1;& 65"6& 65.&
$1K:2L"6$:1"*&+:162$MJ6$:1&6:&65.&72:7.2&6$L.&K2:L&65.&MJMM*.&#.*:+$64&+::2%$1"6.&.ZJ"*3&
65.& 37"+.6$L.& +:162$MJ6$:1& "6& 65.& MJMM*.U3& +5"2"+6.2$36$+& #.*:+$64(& H6& 65.& MJMM*.& -"**&
L:#$1;&"6&#.*:+$64&<
;
8
_5.&+5"2"+6.2$36$+&$1K:2L"6$:1"*&#.*:+$64&K:2& 65.& MJMM*.& +::2%$1"6.& $3&'&
?
9'X&‚&[
<
&P<
;
9,R`&
;$#$1;8
r:2&<
;
&Y&<(?,8&}&u&,9P<(E\R&u&NE[[+l+Dh
\
+&(&r:2&<
;
&Y&,&P*$;56&37..%R8&}&Y&,9PE\R&u&NE[[+l+Dh
[
+
&&Y&{g
73Y?L
(&_5.&+:$1+$%.1+.&:K&65.&6-:&+:J7*$1;&3+"*.3&"6&<
;
&Y&,&"1%&7
3
&Y&?&L&3J;;.363&"&%..7&
+:11.+6$:1&M.6-..1&65.&2"%$J3&"1%&#.*:+$64&%.;2..3&:K&K2..%:L&"6&2.*"6$#$36$+&37..%3`&-5$+5&
L.2$63&KJ265.2&$1#.36$;"6$:1(
Λ
E
('&
?
/'τ)
E
~ <
;
E
'.
E
P)(?<R
Λ ~ ,
E
[
<
&<
;
= ,E\&P<
;
9,R
P)(??R
